It was nuts, but the bar staff was killing it. Lobster Pasta was legit. Live music outside to hold the time, and they had a waitress running drinks to guests waiting outside, which I wish every restaurant did.
1 - 10 of 138 reviews
Wife, daughter, son-in-law and granddaughter went to the restaurant across the street overlooking the bay located close to their boat on a rainy day. Pond along side had nice fish pond which the granddaughter liked. In side was dark wood furniture, hard to sit on....More
I'm honored to know that we'll be seeing you again, William, and thanks so much for all the kind words and input. We truly strive to deliver a five-star dining experience every time, and I can't wait to welcome you back here again to show...More
This is simply the best overall dining experience in the hamptons when weighing all the variables of food quality, portions, service, atmosphere and overall price value- not formal or fancy but certainly hip and cool- it's just an outstanding place!! The only bummer - it's...More
Wow -- thank you so much, John! It is a sincere honor that you consider us to be the best place in town, and earning your kind words and recommendation truly mean the world. Here's to having you back to do it all over again...More
I can't get enough of the food , drinks, atmosphere and friendly staff at Edgewater. Nothing better than going to a restaurant where everyone smiles and greets you and provides great service. The food is always amazing from the lobster pasta to the roasted salmon...More
Wow, thank you so much! It sincerely means the world to see how much you love the food and service here, and having you share your kind words with everyone is a real honor. I hope we get to see you here again real soon!...More
The family who owns this takes great prime in their restaurant. We have never had anything less than an excellent meal here. Do try it if you are in the Hampton Bays area.
I am sincerely honored to have earned such kind praise, and thank you so much for sharing your wonderful enthusiasm with everyone else. I hope we get to see you again some time very soon! Best, John
We eat here often and also had my daughters Communion celebration here. The food is amazing. The service is great. One of the best restaurants!!!More
I'm beyond flattered that we've become one of your favorite restaurants, and it's even more of an honor that you chose to come here for such a special celebration. Thank you so much for everything -- we can't wait to see you all again! Best,...More
Beautiful out door seating, or while waiting for a table. Great food with a varied menu. Great wine and drinks, a bit noisy inside, so I prefer outside only.
I'm glad that you've always had such a lovely time with us, Lin. I can't thank you enough for passing along your kind words and recommendations, and we all look forward to seeing you again! Best, John
Edgewater is a wonderful dining experience with the added pleasure of water views from both its inside and outside seating areas. Italian specialties dot the menu which also features local seafood and weekday specials. NYC - style service is a welcome bonus. Casual and classy...More
Rosalie, it's wonderful hearing you enjoyed our menu and views! I look forward to seeing you back for another relaxing evening and hope to see you soon. Warmly, John
Been going to Edgewater for yrs and have never had a disappointing experience. Food is very good and consistent. It's our go to place. It's quite busy, even in the off season and they only take reservations for larger parties. The bar area is a...More
Thanks for dining with us all these years and for your admiration. I'm delighted you love our food and staff and am looking forward to seeing you again soon. Warmly, John
The food at Edgewater is of very high quality and (for the Hamptons) fairly reasonably priced. They have a 2 for 1 deal from 5-7PM, so the place fills up fairly early, at least in the winter. Service could not have been better. Nothing revolutionary...More
I'm delighted hearing you were pleased with both our food and service and look forward to seeing you when you visit again! Thanks for taking the time to reach out, and have a pleasant rest of your day. Best, John