Poor service. Appetizers served without plates. Food was not great. Lobster was over cooked. Over priced.
1 - 10 of 95 reviews
Stopped for lunch on the way out to Southhampton and food was great... really fresh... sit outside at picnic tables... no ambience because it's right on the parking lot... but, everything you eat there is delicious.
This is a very cool authentic fish spot off the road. Rustic and welcoming place. It looks like a fish store but you can select the fish and they will cook it for you. Good beers and oysters.
After a great day on the beach along the Peconic, we headed back west to go home. Of course traffic is full after a summer weekend leaving the forks, but we knew we were going to cruise Montauk Hwy anyway. The family was hungry so...More
We went there running away from the restaurants in Southampton where the ladies only eat kale salads and organic juices.. A road side restaurant where fresh fis is sold and cooked, to dine in or to take away. Not a fancy restaurant at all, but...More
Great find!! No frills, no reservations but lots of fresh seafood and great prices too! This was our first time at Out of the Blue and we will be stopping in again real soon! The staff there is friendly. Dave who runs the place is...More
Went for dinner with the family and were able to enjoy some simple but very tasty fish. The swordfish was well cooked and tasty with some added hot sauce and lemon. The buckets are good for a table share or meal. Tuesday's 2-4-1 deal is...More
Really great seafood for takeout. Definitely not a great sit down place, but we still eat in side. Service guys are great cannot beat the prices & taste of food just not a fancy overpriced place like the other places in Hampton Bays. Always packed...More