We were skeptical about "NY" style Pizza! Many places say this but fail. But not this one. The crust was thin and well cooked and the cheese was great! I give this NY Pizza a thumbs up. We'll be back!
1 - 10 of 309 reviews
This pizza place is a very good choice! This restaurant has a variety of menu items from wings, pizzas, burgers, to wraps, pasta, and more. My family ordered a variety of menu items, and we were pleased with all of our choices. We also liked...More
In Cooperstown for an annual adult baseball camp and went to New York Pizzaria after a day of playing baseball. We brought most our team and the nine of us were looking forward to the three pizzas we had picked. Then we were informed they...More
Have visited NY Pizzeria on VERY busy Saturday nights of Induction Weekend. Staff is friendly and they are as efficient as they can be given their small town regular business practice that explodes on this weekend each year. You may have to wait for your...More
My wife found New York Pizzeria on Trip Advisor when planning our vacation. We planned to have dinner there July 2. After visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame we arrived about 715 PM, July 2. Ordered at the front counter, and the staff was very...More
OMG !!!! I was told by an acquaintance in my hometown (PA) that I HAD to go to NY Pizzeria for their white garlic broccoli pizza and boy am I glad I did! I told my husband about it and he requested that I bring...More
Want pizza this is the place. Was in copperstown for the week and this was the best place to grab something to eat compared to the other places we tried.
Service is not the best here, but the food is above average (can only speak for their pizza). Parking is difficult due to the location.