We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
See all (71)
See all (71)
Reserve a table
2
Sun, 26/06
20:00
OR
Get food delivered

Ratings and reviews

4.5 192 reviews
#1 of 15 Restaurants in Bayville
RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere

Details

PRICE RANGE
$15 - $30
CUISINES
American, Steakhouse, Bar, Seafood, Pub
Meals
Dinner, After-hours, Drinks
View all details
features, about

Location and contact

275 Bayville Ave Unit A, Bayville, NY 11709-1708
Website
Email
+1 516-628-2000
Improve this listing
Reviews (192)
Write a review
Filter reviews
191 results
Traveller rating
126
48
9
5
3
Traveller type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
Traveller rating
126
48
9
5
3
Show reviews that mention
All reviews shrimp chilli granny smith apples warm apple crisp food is excellent birthday party daily specials the wait staff appetizers
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed 31 March 2022
Very Good Experience

We were visiting family in Mill neck and choose Mill Creek Tavern because they have a very nice menu. I like that they print the daily specials with descriptions and prices. It was a late dinner and both my wife and I opted for appetizers....She selected the Iron Skillet Meatball Parmesan . four homemade meatballs with melted mozzarella, and a pomodoro sauce with a piece of garlic bread on top. Very good. I chose the Crispy Chili Pop Shrimp , baby shrimp( not that small) with a sweet Thai chili sauce, really very good. Also the Tuscan Calamari, fried calamari, marinara, lemon, and a horseradish aioli. Unfortunately the calamari was rubbery and chewy. For dessert, my wife wanted the WARM APPLE CRISP ,Granny Smith apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, rolled oat crumb topping, and vanilla bean ice cream, also very good and a huge portion.More

Date of visit: March 2022
Helpful?
Reviewed 15 February 2022
Valentine’s Day And Anniversary Dinner!!

We Frequent this restaurant as much as possible!! As I am in the Restaurant business myself so I don’t get out much!! But it is My Wife & I Go To Place!! Food is excellent and service is Fast & Friendly!! Thank for another Wonderful...Night Out Great Job!! We will be back Soon!!!More

Date of visit: February 2022
Helpful?
Reviewed 24 October 2021 via mobile
Wonderfully unique and flavorful dishes!

We are visiting from Ohio and tried this place two nights ago and enjoyed it so much we came back tonight. I had the German Goulash, my daughter had the scallops, and my husband had the Orecchiette pasta, which was a seasonal dish. All were...exceptional. The wait staff is super friendly and helpful choosing what to eat.More

Date of visit: October 2021
Helpful?
Reviewed 22 June 2021
100th Birthday Party!

We held a wonderful 100th birthday party at Mill Creek a few months back when the outdoor tent was still up. Our 30 guests were all very pleased with the service and wonderful food. The owner really went out of his way to make us...feel welcome and valued as his guests. It isn't often that you meet someone like this running a restaurant. Very accommodating and pleasant even while dealing with a pandemic. And Vanessa is wunderbar!More

Date of visit: September 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed 8 March 2020 via mobile
Tonight came to Mill Creek

Tonight came to Mill Creek for dinner and to my surprise ordered the special ...Chatham Cod Piccata amazing piece of fish served with asparagus capers tomato with a lovely white wine butter sauce To die for highly recommend it Again another great meal at the...Mill Creek !!!!! And a nice cocktail and desert to complimentMore

Date of visit: March 2020
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded 30 October 2020

Thank you so much for the amazing review! We are so grateful to have you as our guest! Hope to have you back soon. -Rich

Reviewed 12 February 2020
Dinner by the Bay

Very homey atmosphere, Beautiful Place, Great Food, Excellent Service. Outstanding German food on the menu but that's not all Something for everyone. i get there every chance I can.

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?1  
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded 4 March 2020

Hi Frank. Thanks for your kind words and five star review. We are grateful for guests like yourself. All the best - Rich

Reviewed 20 January 2020
Lovely Winter Dinner Night Out With Friends

Such a nice atmosphere having dinner by the fireplace warm and cozy along with excellent food ,everyone enjoyed their apps and entree selections and desserts ,we brought a couple who had never been here and they are in love with this place now and said...will be back again ,Winter or Summer its such a great place the food is always so good here !More

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded 4 March 2020

Hi Joe. Thanks for introducing your friends to Mill Creek. We look forward to serving you again soon - Rich

Reviewed 29 December 2019 via mobile
Little place by the bay

Met a friend for dinner after the Christmas holiday and decided to go to the Mill Creek Tavern I ordered the Scallop Shrimp risotto which was amazing with a Cesar salad and the other order was Shrimp wrap which was delicious as well Would highly...recommend this Bayville Restaurant Staff attentive and warm so is the atmosphere Regards SharonMore

Date of visit: December 2019
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded 4 March 2020

Hi Sharon. Thanks for your kind words and awesome review. All the best - Rich

Reviewed 15 August 2019 via mobile
Great Food in Bayville!

My husband and I have frequented this local restaurant near our home for at least 2 years now. The food is always freshly prepared and delicious! The servers are also very pleasant and accommodating. We usually order pasta with clams, fresh mussels, or another seafood...dish. The menu has a great variety of dishes to choose from. I would highly recommend this local gem!More

Date of visit: June 2019
Helpful?2  
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded 10 December 2019

Thanks for the 5 stars and kind words. I would also like to thank you for your loyalty for the past two years. All the best - Rich

Reviewed 12 July 2019
Excellent food- relaxed setting!

Went with tripadvisor recommendations and gave Mill Creek Tavern a try with friends on a Wednesday evening....we were seated right away with a reservation and the place was pretty busy (both the bar and restaurant)....service was very good, albeit a bit slow at times....place is...casual - no need to dress up....the food is the reason you go here- excellent fresh salads, fish dishes, ribs all very tasty and delicious...and the desserts are also really good! We did have a slight problem finding a parking space- the lot next to the restaurant is small. Overall excellent dining experience!!More

Date of visit: July 2019
Helpful?
Rich3636, Owner at Mill Creek Tavern, responded to this reviewResponded 10 December 2019

Thanks for taking the time out to post and thanks for the 5 stars. We are so happy the you found us. Hope to srr you soon - Rich

View more reviews
123456…
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
The Tides Motor Inn
45 reviews
4.30 km away
The Mansion at Glen Cove
1,715 reviews
7.15 km away
East Norwich Inn
140 reviews
7.26 km away
Hampton Inn & Suites Huntington Downtown
1 review
11.19 km away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
The Crescent Beach Club
67 reviews
.43 km away
Twin Harbors Restaurant
42 reviews
.50 km away
Wall's Wharf
190 reviews
.56 km away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Bayville Scream Park
168 reviews
2.82 km away
Shu Swamp Preserve - Charles T Church Nature Preserve
15 reviews
3.30 km away
Bailey Arboretum
23 reviews
3.78 km away
Sagamore Hill National Historic Site
490 reviews
4.60 km away
See the best nearby hotelsSee the best nearby restaurantsSee the best nearby attractions
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
luckyman56
10 August 2016|
AnswerShow all 5 answers
Response from wetherlee | Reviewed this property |
unfortunately, no. It is near the water, about a block away but not on the water. Wall's Wharf is on the water in Bayville, however, and offers a great menu for beach dining.
0
Votes
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Mill Creek Tavern
Yes, Mill Creek Tavern offers takeaway services.
Mill Creek Tavern is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travellers:
  • Food: 4.5
  • Service: 4.5
  • Value: 4
  • Atmosphere: 4.5