This is definitely a place we will return to. Very unique seating arrangements and great menu. The staff was very attentive!
1 - 10 of 140 reviews
Our 1st visit was for our anniversary dinner beginning of June. We then went back 2 weeks later with another couple for our 2nd visit and one week later for our 3rd visit. Restaurant, service and food makes a lasting impression. We've had the seafood...More
We enjoyed our experience here very much. The place is very unique in how it's set up with their private tables in alcoves. Some people have reviewed that people walking by is bothersome, but it's not like there are endless streams of folks passing. The...More
Had a very nice dinner here. We enjoyed the cuisine very much. Love the atmosphere. Very eclectic. The sauces were especially interesting to me. I was introduced to the chef who described the process for creating the sauce for the rack of lamb which was...More
This is a very interesting and romantic restaurant. If you are a couple or two go in through the ground floor as the tables going up the stairs are either for two or four people. If you have trouble walking stairs or are a larger...More
Hello, and thank you for taking the time to leave us such a great review! We are glad you enjoyed your recent visit to Scarborough Fair and appreciate the sincere comments about our food and service. We hope to serve you again soon!
We came here for a romantic Valentine's Day dinner on 2/14/17. Were we ever deceived! They advertise that they are a very romantic restaurant with "private dining alcoves" and romantic "nooks" and on their website. They have pictured beautiful private tables. That was not the...More
I am so sorry to hear that you felt deceived during your visit. While we would love for every one of our guests to be able to dine at private, romantic alcove tables, we only have a select number of them. I sincerely apologize that...More
My Wife ordered Sole Special with Scallops. Scallops seemed undercooked. Sole was smothered in Sauce. She was awake all night nauseous from the food. I ordered Veal Shank. Not something that I would normally eat, but, I couldn't find anything else. It was fair, at...More
Please accept our most sincere apologies. We’re so very sorry to hear that you and your wife was feeling ill after dining with us. We pride ourselves on using proper food preparation techniques and sanitation methods, so we take reports like this extremely seriously. I...More
My husband took me here for our anniversary. I was totally blown away by the atmosphere and food! It's very quiet and romantic. The food was just as great as the atmosphere! It also has a chocolate store in the same parking lot which is...More
The atmosphere at Scarborough Fair is amazing. The place is unique in its design. That would be enough for me to return. however the food and service were also outstanding. We were there for lunch and I can't wait to return for the dinner menu....More
Jeff, thanks for the compliments! We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed the atmosphere and design of our dining room, and that the shrimp cocktail and grilled salmon were delicious. We look forward to your next visit to explore the dinner menu!