Never disappoints. Service good, food great. Great ambience. Dress is from relaxed, casual, to dressy, formal. You can eat anything from burgers to prime rib. Best to have reservations because always busy.
Does this restaurant have private dining rooms?
Is this restaurant romantic?
Is this restaurant appropriate for Kids?
Does this restaurant have a TV?
Does this restaurant offer takeout or food to go?
Is this restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Is this restaurant good for lunch?
Is this restaurant family-friendly?
Is this restaurant good for dinner?
Are the prices at this restaurant mid-range / moderate?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
Have dined here about once a month for many years. Always a great meal. Bounce between Italian and steak. Nice place for couples, a group or family.
I have eaten at Sibley Gardens on several occasions, primarily with a medium size group (20). They have a perfect room for us. The food is always good,,,I have never heard anyone complain about their meal. The service is always good. Prices are very good for the quality.
We went for a date night and ordered the shrimp and Brussels sprouts appetizer, the Steak Sammy and the filet mignon. We had the beef mushroom soup, and I had the mashed potatoes as my side, while my husband got the loaded twice baked potato. The food was all very delicious except the twice baked potato dish was dry and... More
Return visit with friends, we like this restaurant as it is family run and not a chain. Although reviews comment that décor is dated we find it comfortable and there is a good range of food, good portions although a little pricey
What can I say about Sibley Gardens that hasn't already been said. It is a must when I come home to Mich. From Fla. It has been around for ever and it has survived the test of time because the food is great, service is friendly and atmosphere is warm. You will not be disappointed. If you have not tried... More
Visited Sibley Gardens with some friends. We had 8pm reservations on Nov. 12. Upon ordering we were told that they didn't have any baked potatoes left. Annoying but ordered the mashed potatoes. A half hour later the waitress came out and told me us they didn't have mashed potatoes either. So I ended up with a Prime Rib served with... More
We decided to try this place after a friend's recommendation. We made a reservation via open table, which was super easy and convenient, and we arrived early. We were greeted promptly, but as we walked in it was like stepping back in time. I half expected to turn the corner and see the cast of Goodfellas in the corner! I... More
Ha! Went for date night with my husband, sat on the bar side. Ordered overpriced appetizer of iceberg lettuce with can of sliced black olives, dried out cheese . When dinner was served the waitress placed in front of me a overcooked piece of chicken breast topped with ketchup and called it chicken parmesean. I think this place lives off... More
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing
Never been, is there a dress code? My wife loves Italian, but I'm from the South (meat and potatoes guy). Is there anything for me?