This restaurant is take out or delivery only but the pizza is "Mighty Fine" as the name of the place indicates!
1 - 10 of 61 reviews
4 out of 5 on the pizza. It was good. I ordered a medium with bacon, mushroom, banana peppers, and garlic. Delivery was prompt. What made the difference was calling in. The guy on the phone was quick and efficient. Good pizza, good price, excellent...More
Ooops! Felt like pizza and remembered a pizza sign from earlier in the day. Walked in and no tables!! Luckily, we were parked close and ate it in the car. Very tasty deep dish. Just plan ahead.
Ordered bone in wings mild and chefs salads no dressing. Chefs salads were full, fresh, and appearance great. Out off all the delivery restaurants in Petoskey...Mighty Fine Pizza is the best. Bone in wings were hot to the touch when delivered. Asked for paper plates...More
Ordered pizza to be picked up after miscommunication between family members about whose night it was to prepare dinner while on vacation in the area. After tasting the pizza I was glad someone screwed up. Pizza was delicious, breadsticks were delicious,
You won't find a better pizza anywhere else in the midwest. Takeout only for this busy place. I suggest that you call ahead and place you order. The salads are great.
Three topping pizza and salad delivered quick and fresh. Telephone ordering was prompt and painless. Definitely recommend.
All meat pizza includes polish and Cajun sausages? Sign me up! Delivery or pickup only. Perfect crust, nonsweet sauce, lots of cheese. Decadent but delicious!