The food was very good. The view is amazing. Jamie our waitress did such a nice job. The maitre d was full of himself. He needs some people skills. Wow. Visit this restaurant but avoid the maitre d, he is quite rude.
1 - 10 of 351 reviews
The meal was fine; nothing that was spectacular. We dined at restaurants across northern Michigan along the eastern shore of Lake Michigan for over a week, and our meal at the Carriage House was about middle-of-the-pack in terms of quality, while being the MOST EXPENSIVE....More
We were on the island a cold-ish weekend in May but with a beautiful view of the lake in the dining room who could care? We both ordered the halibut which was perfectly prepared. Our smoked whitefish cake appetizer was also tasty. Our waitress was...More
My favorite place to sit out and have a glass of wine and the Chicken Salad plate. Excellent service and food. RELAX,
Had dinner here the 2nd weekend in October while staying on the island for a couple of nights. Not inexpensive, but superb food and excellent service with a wonderful view of the harbor area. Our server was Abby from Arizona, and while she admitted she...More
We made reservations for dinner here....it is a wonderful restaurant with gorgeous views, varied menu, and friendly staff. The food is prepared just to your specifications....it is fresh and delicious. Will eat here again!
We had dinner at the Carriage House a few days ago. Our dinners were very good and the atmosphere of the restaurant is outstanding. The dining room faces the water which is a perfect location. Service was good.