Great Sunday Brunch, Though pricey. the food and service is always excellent in the restaurant side, haven't be on the bar side.
Can a vegan person get a good meal at this restaurant?
Can a vegetarian person get a good meal at this restaurant?
Is this restaurant good for lunch?
Is this restaurant good for dinner?
Does this restaurant specialize in Halal food?
Is this a Kosher restaurant?
Does this restaurant offer valet parking?
Does this restaurant offer validated parking?
Is this primarily a bakery?
Is this primarily a coffee shop?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
Considering a number of dinners needed to be served, the food and waitstaff were excellent. I would highly recommend this restaurant for any time of function.
I wish there were more stars to give! Everything was incredible. The warm decor , the wonderful service and the delicious food all made for fantastic dining experience. We can't wait to return.
cherie1220 - I read your review with such a smile on my face. Thank you for writing it and thank you for dining with us and I hope every future will be 5-star. Many Thanks! Sheila More
The very best baked stuffed lobster ever....order ahead. The stuffing was made with a generous serving of scallops and shrimp and perfectly cooked. Every bite was a religious experience.
ClayBarnstable - Many thanks for the review and for the description - cannot get any better than that. Anytime you get the craving for that lobster, give us a call - we will be happy to oblige! We appreciate your business! Sheila More
Took the in-laws for a 92nd bday celebration last week! Sat in the cozy tavern area. Portions were large & the food was great. Our waiter, Dave, was excellent and took very good care of us. We live in Eastham so we need to really like a place to travel far to it!
Thank you for your review and for making the trek from Eastham! We appreciate that you chose the Old Yarmouth Inn for such a fabulous celebration, and thank you for your nod to David's service. We hope to see you again! Sheila More
The Old Yarmouth Inn was founded in 1696 but it was new to us when we stopped in for lunch. The Old Yarmouth Inn is well maintained and handsome not hinting at its colonial era roots. The restaurant has a good menu full of tempting choices and a friendly inviting staff. For lunch we started with the butternut squash bisque... More
NYMike120 Thank you for your review and for choosing to stop in join us for Lunch. Our Daily specials are always a good bet if you want something a little less traditional than our Full Lunch menu and I am sure that Gretchen will be hear (and will surely remember you) the next time you come in. Many Thanks, Sheila More
We made dinner reservations but came early to enjoy a drink or 2 at the bar. I will have to say that service at the bar was not good. Each time my wife and my drink was empty, we were not asked if we would like a refill or something else. We had to wait for him to come over... More
JasonW - I am very sorry to hear that what should have been a five-star experience was marred by indifferent service at the bar. We take pride in offering exceptional service to new-comers and long standing patrons and apologize that we fell short. I hope that this will not keep you from returning to the Old Yarmouth Inn. Many thanks,... More
I made reservations for New Year's Day just in case. We were seated at 5pm. The lobby was beautiful and cozy with a roaring fire in the huge fireplace. We were seated in a beautifull dining room. Our waiter was informative as well as attentive without being intrusive. We had a delicious dinner. It was a lovely evening on a... More
MrsP3333 - Thank you for your "awesome" review. We are sol pleased that you enjoyed the entire experience; atmosphereand service included and hope you will be back to see as again soon. Many Thanks, SHeila More
Had the occasion to visit the Old Yarouth Inn last evening with a party of 13, including children. Everything was beyond excellent from the great service to the awesome food ! Cannot recommend this outstanding family owned establishment enough ! You will feel both like family and spoiled by all the OYI has to offer.
Without the loyal support of people like you and others in the neighborhood, around the Cape and from as far away as Naples we wouldn't be here. We have committed ourselves to good service, friendly staff and a welcoming environment for 20 years. Thanks for letting us know we are doing it right!! Many Thanks, Sheila More
I was a guest at a Holiday Party and again, the Old Yarmouth Inn delivered. we ordered from a menu with three courses. This was not your typical meat, fish chicken affair. we had 8 or 10 entrees to choose from - ironically I had the Pecan chicken with beat risotto. I can speak for everyone at our table, every... More
Thank you for your review. The entire team pulls together to ensure that our large parties get the same care and attention and HOT food as the smaller parties. Thanks for letting us know that we are doing it right! Many thanks Sheila More
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing
Are you having a special menu this coming Sunday for Valentine's Day and do we have to make reservations?