A nice small pizza place. The meatballs sub was delicious and the Italian club was really good and they are all very filling. Fresh ingredients and the guy makes his dough in the back. Can play mrs PAC man while you wait.
1 - 10 of 52 reviews
Yeah I said it, the best on Cape Cod! I have always loved Toly's pizza. The sauce is just right, the cheese blend perfection and the pan cooked crust is crispy and golden! Everything right, always delicious, never disappointed!
From the highway Toly,s doesn't look like much, but don't let that fool you! I'm looking forward to my next pizza there! They'll make up almost combination you might want. Several times when we each wanted something different he did a pizza half & half....More
Toly's recently added kitchen equipment that allows them to offer more menu items. Now you can get fried fish and chips, chicken tenders, french fries and burgers on the grill. Subs made on the grill include steak & cheese. Something for everyone. Eat in or...More
This is the best pizza on the Cape. Every year we order a dozen or more pies for our large group. The pies are always delicious and ready on time!
My wife and her family have been coming here for years. I was first introduced to Toly's about 16years ago. It is not much to look at from the outside as it is very dated and old but looks can be deceiving. The pizza is...More
Toly's has been here for years and the pizza is good and the people are nice. Conveniently located on Route 28 in Yarmouth. Prices in line with other pizza places in the area.