Smallest portions I've ever seen for mediocre food at a premium price. Owners need to understand this is Newbury, MA not Newbury St.
1 - 10 of 171 reviews
Fun drinks and a gorgeous view from the bar of the sunset. Mainly seafood but a few options for vegetarians and non seafood lovers. The cheese plate was delish and the cheese is made locally. Friendly staff. Fun atmosphere. Good vacation vibes. Try the Ruby...More
We have been coming here for years - its always been fun to hang out on the small deck with drinks enjoying the view of the marsh & sunset, or in the open bar area. But sadly, tonite it appears the place has gone to...More
Good meal and great staff but we were unable to carry on a conversation due to loud people at surrounding tables and the bar. Won't return as conversation without yelling should be part of the dining experience.
We had dinner here. The windows and doors were open with a beautiful breeze off the salt marshes. The food was very good as were the drinks. Swordfish was excellent. It was a great island experience.
I was with a party of 5 women celebrating a bachelorette on Plum Island this past weekend. We had a great experience of the restaurant. Our server was attentive and prompt and happy to answer all our questions. I had the BEST ribs I have...More
My daughter and I had dinner at Plum Island Grille while visiting in Newburyport, MA. We ordered a small plate of sea scallops with brussel sprouts and had their sangria. The food was very very good and the small portion was perfectly satisfying for our...More
Made. 7 PM reservation. Wife and I had a drink at the beautiful Sunset Bar. Paid check, bartender knocked over water glass , water in my wife's lap. No big deal, it is water. We were seated for dinner at 7PM. 20 minutes pass, no...More
After spending the afternoon in Newburyport and walking on the beach at Plum Island, we had a delicious dinner at the Plum Island Grille. Though it was a busy Saturday night and we didn't have a reservation, the host asked us if we could finish...More
My sister and I had dinner here tonight - she just moved to Newburyport a month ago. There are many nice places to eat "in town" but we decided to try the Plum Island Grille tonight. Cars were parked up and down the street so...More