Buffy’s is the ultimate old school ice cream experience! Even off season. The staff is amazing…so friendly! And my Chatham Ice cream birthday bar was decadent. Worth every penny.
Buffy’s is the ultimate old school ice cream experience! Even off season. The staff is amazing…so friendly! And my Chatham Ice cream birthday bar was decadent. Worth every penny.
Outstanding! Fresh cookies, ice cream. Great service. Reese PB one was the hands down favorite. Cookie dough was good as well.
Lived here on cape cod for 25 years and the first time I've been here makes me never want to leave. Perfectly small ice cream shop
We visited Buffys today while wandering Chatham. The owner was very engaging, and explained his house-made ice cream and ice cream bars. We each had waffle cones with two different flavors, and it was wonderful! Creamy, great flavor, and served at the perfect temperature. Loved...it!More
On the Cape for a wonderful week and visited Buffy's 3 times...wish we were here longer...my husband just loved their homemade brownies and I loved the coffee ice cream as well as ice cream sandwiches
Hi Ann, thank you so much for your kind comments — I’m so glad you enjoyed Buffy’s and Chatham Ice Cream Bars!!!
This was the best ice cream ever. The ice cream sandwiches were amazing. Went back 4 times during my vacation. Can’t wait to go back.
The staff were very friendly and patient and the ice cream was delicious. Lots of flavors to choose from and they have their own specialty home-made ice cream bars.
A venerable Chatham institution thankfully has been rejuvenated under new ownership and with the incorporation of artisanal Chatham Ice Cream Bars. All flavors and bars made on site. Freshly-squeezed lemonade and lime rickeys. Best afternoon sun-dappled dessert bar on the Cape! Worth a visit and...many sweet returns.More
We stopped for a late dessert one evening. The service was fast and ice cream was fresh and tasted great! I especially liked that the flavor I got (mocha choco chip) was not too sweet.
Went with my family during a summer vacation. Super service; fantastic ice cream; a must to anyone traveling to Chatham.
Female manager is truly awful. Called to order hand packed pints and she snapped that she needed 24 hours notice as her line was so long. We were driving by and there were only two people in the store. Same rude manager last year, so...we decided to call Cape Cod Creamery rather than go inside and deal with her attitude. Cape Cod Creamery staff was absolutely amazing and had a great product. Even delivered curbside.More
they have a bunch of unique flavors on the menu, but i just didn't think they ended up actually tasting that great. I tried Pistachio and Maple Walnut and they were more bland and less creamy than i would have liked.
great homemade ice cream in the center of Chatham on Main St, very friendly staff. A small store but great selection
Lots of different ice creams to choose from, and they have several non-dairy choices which tasted lovely.
Delicious homemade ice cream, but very crowded at night with a long line which tells you how good it is.