We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travellers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travellers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
My spouse and I had aThanksgiving meal away from home at Fager's. The meal blew my socks off. I felt like I was at home at my mother's table. It was prepared with love. I was so excited when I saw the plate and tasted...the first bite that I failed to say grace. Well, I'm thankful for the cooks in the kitchen and the warm greeting coming and leaving. We'll be back!More
Took our family of 5 (1 8yo.) for the Thanksgiving dinner here and it was great. All of the food was good to great in the fixed plate meal, and we added some ala cartel apps that were fabulous.
The absolute best part of the...whole meal was our server, Barb, who was friendly, efficient, and just fun on what was surely a busy day. Special thanks to her.More
We were part of a foursome, being treated for our anniversary to the fine dining area. Our guest had the waiter provide us with a bottle of their branded brut champagne; a nice touch. Downhill from there. Appetizers were disappointing. Both Escargots and Oyster Rockefeller...were tasteless. Largest problem was my Prime Rib. Huge in size, but little in quality. Was not prime grade, not even choice grade. Unable to cut it with the serrated knife. Informed the waiter, who suggested another prime rib, from another part of the roast. Not agreeable to that. Finally accepted his recommendation on the filet mignon, which finally arrived after some of our party had finished eating. The meat was soaked in caramelized onions, and tasted like onion soup. Terrible. Wife and I will not be back.More
I used to love going to fagers island and I've never had a bad experience For 30 years until now , tonight we had the worst meal of our life had to send back a fillet mignon 3 times to prepare medium ...and it was...raw...I don't know where the hec they got their chef from but he must have just came out of a trailer park because he has no idea what the fock he's doing... we just spend a $155 for a piece of sh!t meal, will not go again!! Let me know when you hire a new chef 🖕🖕🖕More
We've been here several times but this night was not a good experience. We had an 8pm reservation for 4, fine dining. We were seated outside, which was great. 4 ladies on a beautiful Saturday evening of a girls weekend. Service was slow and spotty...at best. Drinks were ordered and the amount of time was beyond embarrassing. We went on to order dinner, 2 of us having swordfish, one ordered sea bass, one scallops. The meals weren't served all together and that is a huge issue for me. My swordfish was warm, at best. I was served a second cocktail, which wasn't ordered, as it was H20i weekend and I was driving. 2 gals ordered dessert, again, painfully long wait. If it was just the wait, it may not have been and but when you come to a restaurant and spend $50+ per person, you expect service ...wasn't here this evening. If you can't accommodate the amount of people, don't accept the reservation. Food was ok, nothing special at all!More
Positive experience. We were told we would have a 30-minute wait, so we enjoyed good drinks and conversation with the bartenders. The wait was only 20 minutes before we were seated by the water with a spectacular view. Our waiter Gavin was busy but remained...very attentive and had a great personality. The table next to us that had a larger group commented the same about him. We enjoyed bacon-wrapped livers, a Caesar salad, burger, a salmon BLT all of which were cooked as requested. We will definitely return.More