Pizza and ice cream. Pizza and ice cream. After a long hike or long nap what’s better than pizza and/or ice cream. Sometimes the wait for pizza is a bit long but it’s worth it. Sometimes I wish it was open at 10pm when the...More
1 - 10 of 56 reviews
We ate lunch at the Novelty and also bought ice cream and wine. They only take cash or check but do have an ATM. The wine is reasonably priced. The sandwiches were very good. They have vegetarian options. Highly recommend.
This little nook of a food store serves the best pizza on the island...ok, maybe the only pizza, but it was delicious! Homemade - no processed, pre-frozen stuff - honest to goodness delicious! And ice cream - BIG cones for you buck, and lots of...More
It was very warm the day we were there and their ice cream hit the spot. A little more expensive than the main land but the scoops were very generous.
The Novelty has good food--sandwiches, pizza, and other casual foodstuff. Ideal for buying your lunch or snack and taking it on your hike to eat with a view. Beer and wine also available as package carryout.
I love the Novelty's BBQ chicken pizza, though it seems a bit pricey. The have a selection of beer, wine and an awesome blueberry soda.
I was amazed by the variety offered by this tiny place. Eat inside or out or take it to go hiking. Staff was very friendly, and save room for the homemade ice cream!