This is Amish in name only. They have some traditional Amish products and a deli counter. Not really exciting. I bought a small item and left. It's not really worth the stop.
1 - 10 of 112 reviews
We planned our stop here for lunch. Sandwiches with choices of bread, meat and cheeses. I had a Veggie grilled cheese with peppers, onions and tomatoes. Dining area was simple and refillable fountain drinks. Found the grocery section to be full of spices, staples, candy,...More
Interesting place to shop for homemade local goods or to eat. I had a Ruben sandwich like the last review but mine was delicious and large. Good variety of local foods. bought a loaf of sourdough bread at a good price and some cranberry honey...More
Another stop to take a travel break and another disappointment. The store had loads of noodles, spices, soup mixes and sweets which was interesting, our cashier was friendly well informed and helpful but the food from the deli was not good at all. The ruben...More
´Tis a grand day. Old Town Amish Store is a desired stopping point. Old Town Amish Store does provide Amish style baked goods. My wife purchases a dozen Kentucky Derby Brownies, two dozen chocolate chip cookies, and three loaves of multi-grain bread. We highly recommend.
Old Town Amish Store was a good suggestion of the Boone Tavern Hotel. Its got a good old fashion atmosphere, the staff were friendly and helpful. The decor was country with wooden tables and chairs. I had black coffee, eggs, biscuit, potatoes.