We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220-3219
+1 317-259-9412
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
  • Excellent67%
  • Very good20%
  • Average7%
  • Poor3%
  • Terrible3%
Travellers talk about
All hours
Italian, Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options
₹₹ - ₹₹₹
1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220-3219
Write a Review
Turn Your Opinions into Points!
Turn your opinions into JPMiles
Turn your opinions into PAYBACK Points
*You can enroll in only one programme at a time to earn rewards for reviews.
JPMiles / Payback Arrow
Reviews (292)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

1 - 10 of 292 reviews

Reviewed 2 weeks ago

Simply put, it was one on the finest dining experiences I have ever had. The food, the service, the wine, the atmosphere......perfect 10's across the board! Every one that I dined with felt exactly the same.

Thank ohioyoungs
Reviewed 3 weeks ago

We sat outside on the beautiful patio. The food was fantastic. The wine (recommended by the server) was OK. The ambiance was wonderful. However, the service, was substandard. Not because things weren't done in a timely manner. It was the manner in which they were...More

Thank Rick E
Reviewed 4 weeks ago

This is a local treasure. Expect a wait any night of the week but especially on weekends. Don't worry, it is worth it. We eat here regularly and intend to visit 10 to 15 times a year.

Thank jasonmA5899QH
Reviewed 17 May 2017

Having read that this was rated the #1 romantic restaurant in ALL of Indiana, we had high expectations. It is a lovely setting. The gardens outside make for an excellent photo op which we took advantage of in documenting our day spent celebrating our anniversary....More

Thank 2011lovinitsteph
Reviewed 17 May 2017

Even though it was a busy night (prom season), we were seated right away. Our server was very attentive and our drinks and food arrived promptly.

Thank Nancy W
Reviewed 10 May 2017

This lovely place was amazing! The garden we walked through to get into the building with outdoor seating was romantic and beautiful. The hostess who seated us was very friendly, We ate in an upstairs room, very cozy. Our waitress was friendly, smiling and attentive...More

Thank donna f
Reviewed 6 May 2017

Very good service, waitress was awesome! Food was genuine Italian with all the amenities. The facility was a converted old residential home that had all the old world charm added.

Thank baty51
Reviewed 30 April 2017 via mobile

Had heard great stuff about this "Romantic restaurant" but I was very disappointed. The waitress was indifferent. No smile. No enthusiasm. She was simply not interested in serving us. The food was not spectacular. The eggplant was too salty and tart because it had an...More

Thank Fulldistance
Reviewed 28 April 2017 via mobile

An absolutely lovely dining spot with a beautiful garden setting and delicious, but somewhat overpriced food. The fish special crusted with Parmesan and cheese risotto wasn't as good as the Italian dish of my spouse. The fish was fried and somewhat dry without a lot...More

Thank Tymetotravel
Reviewed 26 March 2017 via mobile

Date night with my hubby and we decided to revisit Mama Carolla's...fond memories of food and flirtation from our first date. We were sadly disappointed with the service and the food...but the flirtation was still awesome! The food was average at best. My ravioli was...More

Thank Pamela J
Nearby Restaurants
120 reviews
.56 km away
Yats on College
205 reviews
.41 km away
Good Morning Mama's Cafe
135 reviews
.05 km away
Nearby Attractions
Indiana State Fairgrounds
115 reviews
2.53 km away
Hinkle Fieldhouse
96 reviews
2.42 km away
Hook's American Drugstore Museum
23 reviews
2.55 km away
Indy Brew Bus
188 reviews
2.08 km away
Questions & AnswersAsk a question
We are coming into town for the DCI Championships and need a place for a large group of parents to get together for an early lunch on Friday August 12. Everyone would need to be on separate checks but would probably be a group of anywhere from 25-50 people. This is the first time we have all tried to get together so not sure just how many people will be able to make it. But we need a definite place and then can get a more accurate number. Is this something your restaurant could handle on a Friday?
31 July 2016|
Answer Show all 5 answers
Response from Ronald N | Reviewed this property |
Since Mama Corolla's is not open for lunch you might consider the restaurants in the nearby section of Broad Ripple. There are numerous locations on the main drag that are open for lunch, have ample room for groups, and the... More
Can you accomodate a group of approximately 25-30? (volleyball team, coaches, chaperones and parents) It would be nice if the team of 10 girls could all sit together at one table.
1 March 2016|
Answer Show all 2 answers
Response from Justin L | Property representative |
Hello, We have room that will seat up to 24. If the 10 girls wanted to be at one table and the parents and others wanted to be in another room, we could do that. When were you looking for the reservation?
Do u have a special menu this year for Valentine's Day and price aswell. I plan on attending on Friday the 12th do I need to plan to make reservations as I know sometimes u guys do this
11 February 2016|
Response from gold-vintner | Reviewed this property |
I would suggest that you call the restaurant. Valentine's Day is special.........and a good choice to impress your lady !!!! Sorry I do know their daily operations. Good luck !!!!!!!!
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Rating summary
  • Food
  • Value
Average prices
US$ 21 - US$ 30
Restaurant features
Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar
Good for
Kids, Child-friendly, Romantic, Special Occasion Dining
Open Hours
17:00 - 21:30
17:00 - 21:30
17:00 - 21:30
17:00 - 22:00
17:00 - 22:00
Location and Contact Information
  • Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220-3219
  • Location: United States  >  Indiana (IN)  >  Indianapolis
  • Phone Number: +1 317-259-9412
  • E-mail
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing