Hasn't changed in here for 40 years, and thank goodness they kept the quality of the pizza right along with that. Nachos and zucchini appetisers are good also. This is a wait on yourself type of place but the food is good
1 - 10 of 119 reviews
Bought two pizza's for pickup. It is always very crowded there and sometimes would rather eat at home. We always buy more than we need just so we can have it for lunch the next day!
I have had pizza from Barnaby's a few times now at family gatherings. I love Lou Malnati's deep dish pizza, but the thin crust sausage and pepperoni from Barnaby's is excellent. The crust, made with cornmeal, I'm told, is quite good.
Came here as it was a quick walk across from the renaissance hotel and there was a snow storm and didn't want to risk the roads. When you enter you have to find your own seat amongst the benches and booths. You then go and...More
Barnaby’s has been at this location seemingly forever. You cannot find a better thin pizza. Couple of problems. There always seem to be a traffic jam of people when picking up food—kind of annoying. They also do not have any parking places set aside for...More
We've gone here for years. The place doesn't have much for ambience but it makes it up in a great thin crust pizza. Not Chicago style, but very very yummy.
Still craving the pizza. It is the best buttery crust and just right amount of sauce and cheese. We have been here twice for our team dinner. It is a great choice as people can pay and order on their own but can sit near...More