This place is open despite the Trip Advisor main description stating otherwise. Is a tiny place on a habit canal. We had a mahi mahi roll that was excellent. Perfectly prepared with slaw and a slightly spicy sauce. We will be back.

AMAZING SERVICE!!!! AMAZING FOOD!!!! The server/hostess/ cashier Anthony explained the menu to us as soon as we walked in, had wonderful charisma, and was very energetic. He told us their best selling items and was very helpful and informative. After we sat he continued to...be helpful and very in tune to our every need. Seating is right on the water and has plenty of shade and seating. Super clean. The food came out quickly. And was absolutely delicious. The vibe is relaxed and just very well put together. We ordered the Ceviche Del Mar- 10/10. The fish was perfect and the sauce although a bit spicy was absolutely amazing. The Roller Lobster roll- 10/10. Quality. Casa Mar Roll- 10/10. Also quality, but if I had to chose, I would say the Lobster roll is better. The proportions are perfect, food is light, and great for hot weather. Definitely leaving 100% satisfied! Hands down would recommend!!More

Stopped here with my husband on our way from Miami to our hotel in islamorada. We were sooo hungry and I looked this place up on trip advisor & couldn’t wait to get a lobster roll! I got the lobster roll but was surprised it...was Maine lobster and not local Florida lobster, it was also $28!! My husband isn’t a fish fan but likes fried calamari so he got the crispy calamari roll. Unfortunately it was full of legs and not many rings & the rings were overcooked. So I was happy and he wasn’t. $50 for 2 sandwiches & 2 cans of soda is pretty expensive!More