Great pizza! Salad was fresh and dressing was delicious. Supreme pizza, Pesto pizza, and pepperoni. Excellent service
1 - 10 of 410 reviews
City Pizza has been a fixture on Siesta Key for many years (25+). Open for lunch & dinner. They offer pizza -of course- hot & cold sandwiches, traditional Italian entrees, calzones, Stromboli, and even pizza by the slice. Service is attentive. Not fast food as...More
Located within Crescent Plaza on Siesta Key, this is definitely a restaurant that serves more than just pizza. There are a large variety of pizzas, including their gluten-free pizza. We wanted to try something a little different.Since there weren't any particular daily specials, I ordered...More
Our family dined at City Pizza our first night of vacation. There weren't many in the restaurant when we arrived, so we got seated quickly and ordered fast. We ordered calamari, which was good. Our salads were very good and came with lots of bread...More
We got take out pizza from here. The toppings were good, but the crust was a bit dry and the pizza needed more sauce and cheese. Overall it was very average.
My husband doesn't like seafood so it was very nice to have brick oven pizza near by accomodations. Staff very friendly and they even took off 10% if paying with cash.
Just the best pizza in town - so very good. Normally we carry out, but stayed in this time. Service was spot on, and the appetizers and meals (other than pizza) were great. This visit was right after Hurricane Irma came through, and they were...More
We went here for lunch one day the weather temporarily cancelled our beach holiday :-). The pizza was quite good and they allowed us to "half-and-half" it (different choice of pizza on each half). We had a tired but friendly waitress who was willing to...More
We loved the location of City Pizza. We could walk to it from Tropical Beach Resorts, right across the street. We went there twice, first time for pizza and drinks, we sat at the bar. Second time just for drinks. The bartender James is amazing!...More
Pizza was ready right on time. Piping hot with plenty of pepperoni; would have liked a little more mushrooms but it tasted great.