I was told about this place by a friend. We went as a group of 20 after a funeral service i have been in the restaurant industry for over 20 years and i was amazed at the service and the awesome food. This is an...More
1 - 10 of 868 reviews
What a great place to eat and to shop. The smorgasbord had a great selection of food and it was excellent. If you love being near the Amish you would love this place.The upstairs store has many amazing things to buy especially if you love...More
Trying to find a place that all would like - this was a great choice for picky eaters. Great homestyle food, salad bar great, clean buffet, and wide variety of veggies. Free ice cream at the end.More
Hi Mombarbara, Thank you for taking the time to review Der Dutchman Sarasota. You are so right that its not always easy to find a place to suit everyone's taste and I am glad you found that with us. We have a wide selection to...More
Three adults had the buffet here on a Thursday night in December 2017. Good solid food. Nothing extraordinary but certainly very acceptable. Roast beef, turkey, ham, fried chicken and fish were the main courses. Costs us about $60 with tax and tip and ice teas....More
Hi Chris, Thanks for stopping in and taking the time to write a review for Der Dutcman Sarasota.
Fantastic dinner with friends. Buffet food was great selection, variety, quality, and taste, Waitress and service all around is great. Facility is beautiful - clean - interesting. Prices are very reasonable for great food.
Der Dutchman has an extensive buffet, but also a menu if you are not interested in multiple plates of salad, salads, fresh veggies (very good), flavorless entrees, and several desserts that usually include soft serve ice cream (machine broken). Maybe this is what Amish cuisine...More
Thank you for taking the time to review Der Dutchman Sarasota. Top quality food is important to us therefore we take your feedback seriously. I do apologize that our ice cream machine was broken down for a few days recently but happy to say that...More
We’ve been here multiple times and it’s always excellent food!!! Excellent service as well!! The bakery in the front has excellent food as well! Would recommend this restaurant/bakery to everyone!!
Tank you Joy_Jay for your review. Excellent food and service is top priority and I am happy that is what you experienced when you came in!
We thoroughly enjoyed this restaurant. We had the lunch buffet which was quite a spread! The fried chicken was fresh and seasoned to perfection. There was a huge salad bar and plenty of fresh baked goods for desert. We highly recommend this to anyone who...More
Hi Stephanie, Thank you for visiting Der Dutchman Sarasota and taking the time to write a review. I am happy your enjoyed your time with us.
A large, well kept family restaurant serving Amish style food along with other style foods. They have a large buffet, well stocked with good food. They also are famous for their pies.
Thank you for your review and kind comments!
We’ve been coming here for many years but it seems less Amish as time goes on. The buffet is large and has many traditional items from salads, creamed corn, broasted chicken, turkey, and deserts. Everything was good, a few sides were outstanding. As for the...More
Hi Steve, Thank you for taking the time to write a review to let us know of your recent visit with Der Dutchman Sarasota. Great service and quality food is very important to us. I apologize that you didn't care for the stir-fry and agree...More