We stopped here after our bike ride around the wildlife refuge. It was a highlight of the day - fabulous ice cream in rocking chairs on the porch.
1 - 10 of 1,979 reviews
Definitely worth standing in line for. All of their ice cream and gelato is homemade and delicious! Can’t say enough about their great service. Since I’m allergic to nuts, when I ordered, they went in the back to get my ice cream from a fresh...More
We had single scoop (large) in a waffle cone for $5 each. The line was very long but we enjoyed the ice cream (pricey).
We have been coming to Sanibel for many years and always end our evenings with ice cream. Pinocchio's is a very popular place and for good reason! They have get friendly service and a wide variety of ice creams and sherbets. They even have a...More
We have frequented this place for years and the prices continue to rise. Tonite was the last straw. They overcharged us by 2 waffle cones (almost $14 worth!!), and made it sound like it was our fault they screwed up. We probably wouldn’t have caught...More
We stopped in based off reviews and really enjoyed the ice cream! We each tried a different kind, but the Almond Wedding Cake was the group favorite! Our only complaint was the sample bid the took from had so many more "chunks" or mix ins...More
I have been coming to Pinocchio's for years. There ice cream has never disappointed me or my family. It is pricy, but it is worth it. The ice cream is made right there. If you ask for a certain flavor at the beginning of the...More
We enjoyed the double chocolate ice cream. It had a nice flavor and it was very creamy. We shared a two scoop bowl.