We travel to Sanibel Island often and each trip involves at least one trip (and usually more) to Pinocchio’s. Best ice cream in the area!
1 - 10 of 1,914 reviews
While in Sanibel, we always make it a point to get sundaes at Pinocchio's. We had hot fudge sundaes in lieu of dinner one evening after a rather filling lunch. They were delicious and just hit the spot!!
If you like ice cream this is the place for you. Huge portions of home-made ice creams with lots of choice of flavours - the dirty sand dollar has got to be the best! Quite a tight fit inside at times but well worth the...More
Huge portions! Delicious ice-cream. The cones are very good! We had to go twice (and would have gone even more times if we had discovered this place earlier on our trip) Please do yourself the favor of eating ice-cream here after a bikeride to the...More
2 Scoops of Double Dark Chocolate with the Cherry Vanilla could not have been better and my wife loved her Key lime Gelato. The quality is a wow and the portions are a double wow. Sitting out on their porch eating delicious ice cream was...More
Decided to have an ice cream lunch; had already read some of the reviews here - so we got the small - and that was PLENTY! Great ice cream, folks; we saw on the porch, ate our ice cream, and people watched.
This is a perfect spot for all ice cream lovers! Delicious, homemade ice cream in more than generous serving sizes. My family raved about it!
We travel as a family every year to Sanibel and visit this place SEVERAL times each trip. I don't eat ice cream but the family does and loves to discover the choices you cannot get anywhere else on the island. Fast, friendly service at a...More