Went here for dinner and got quite a surprise, the service was so great the food was exceptional, we enjoyed the pizza, strombolie ,and the Italian wings. We will always come back here,If you like Italian homemade food this is the place to go to.
1 - 10 of 295 reviews
Primo pizza lunch with a soft drink for $6 !!! Do not miss this place or blow it off because of it's "gas station" appearance. This is NOT gas station pizza! I can't wait to come back to try a real sit down meal.
You have no idea what you've been missing! I was born and raised in St. Augustine and this is one restaurant that I eat at EVERY week :) When you eat here, you will realize Carmelo's has something it going on and her name is...More
I personally think pizza is God's most perfect food, and that Carmelo's is the best pizza on the planet. Everything seems perfectly balanced, not too much salt, oil, toppings or trendy crust. If you have one piece left, you always take it home for later....More
We were a bit concerned about a pizza from a gas station but we decided to try it because of recommendations from friends. We were not disappointed.
So its a part of a gas station , But you would not know it once you sit down, I like it.Lots of fresh pizza displayed with flare.
We had lunch at Carmelo's Pizzeria while waiting for our tour across the street at Whetstone Chocolates. We wanted something close, and I'm glad it was. As another reviewer stated, don't let the location keep you from going, as it's adjacent to a gas station....More
Don't be fooled by the location. It is just a short walk from Old Town adjacent to a gas station. The restaurant interior is modern and upscale. The pizza is very good. We just got a small cheese pizza because we needed a light meal....More