Great little place with super seafood and one-of-a-kind atmosphere. Grouper, flounder, shrimp were all flavorful. Hush puppies are excellent. Reasonable prices, good portion sizes.
1 - 10 of 150 reviews
Excellent oysters! Granddaughter ordered the ' gator tail' and gave it a rave review. Robin, our waitress was attentive, efficient and very personable. A definite positive experience which we will repeat when we escape the winter cold next year.
I LOVE fresh Oysters on the Half Shell and when I'm in the mood to eat them fresh shucked I go to Gary's. You can get them shucked right at the bar and eat them right away. Get a bucket, with horseradish and hot sauce...More
A large group dined on the oysters on a Friday night. Oysters were fresh and very large. The gumbo is a family favorite as well as the clam chowder. The gumbo has a bite to it. Disappointed that they didn't have any IPA on tap...More
if you eat here...you will leave hungry! portions are small...very costly for what you get! disappointed! wont be back...
We did not want a chain restaurant, we wanted a small hometown restaurant and this one fit the bill. This is not a pretty place, but it is really good. One ordered an appetizer of raw oysters for some to try and all that ate...More
I only have 1 drink a week so I ordered the Margarita and when the waitress served it I thought she made a mistake and gave me soda because it was served in a styrofoam cup! It really takes away from the drink and it...More
Gary's has been around for a long time. And it's understandable. Known for the oysters, they do not disappoint. They are large, fresh and delicious. Early bird menu is really good too. Regular menu is a bit pricey for the place. But well worth going...More
Tonight was our first time going to Gary's Oyster Bar. The food was delicious and the beer was cold. Our waitress was friendly and the service was fast. We had conch fritters, a dozen raw oysters and the broiled seafood sampler, and everything was delicious....More
I primarily order the oysters when I come here, after all, it is an oyster bar. They are always very fresh and shucked right in front of you. The waiters are friendly and the owner is a hoot!! If you are looking for a good...More