Yummy.... from the jelly beans , taffy to the BBQ sauces they are all amazing. Definitely get the chocolate dipped key lime pie frozen treat...

They are open Monday through Sunday from 9:30 AM to 9:30 PM. Great key lime pie they also have extra tart. I ordered the traditional Mini pie. Locally made ice cream.

I spent most of my time in Key West not being able to even try any desserts because everything was made with nuts, had nuts, etc etc. This was the first place that we called that had nut free pies. We enjoyed the mini pies....I suggest you promote this nut free option- its a BIG market.More

Admittedly I am the key lime fan of my family, but the little shop offers something for everyone. I had the mini pie, while two others in the party opted for key lie pie slices. The pies are fluffy and delicate. The two littles had...a vanilla and a strawberry shake. The limeade was exactly what it is, and while the teen who ordered didn't care for it (he also doesn't like key lime pie or lemonade), I thought it was great. Definitely worth a visit!More

Stopped in on a deathly hot day and shared a pie with the family. Nice tart flavor, could have used better whipped cream and a little thicker crust.

This place is small and quaint. I had a slice of the key lime pie and was not disappointed! It had the perfect amount of sweet and tart, creamy, cool, and so refreshing on a hot summer’s day!

We are in search of the best key lime pie in the area. This was a string contender for #2. It is very well made. The tart filling is super strong. My husband tried the coconut key lime and it was the best of our...order.More

My only desert weakness is Key Lime pie so I had to try some in Key West. We stopped here and was glad I did. It was perfect! I’m just sad I couldn’t take some home..

Delicious, fresh key lime pie here! We prefer the extra-tart because it's a little more "limey". Friendly staff, clean restaurant, yummy snacks!

We visited the Key West pie company in May of 2022. We walked in the store and found they removed all of Pete's Candy and the shop only had one display and was very sparsely decorated. We tried the pie and the filling tasted more...like a pudding than a key lime filling, we were disappointed in the flavor and the shop itself. I love Key Lime Pie and tried 6 different ones in the 4 days I was in the Keys, I love "The Profit" but this was in the bottom 2.More

the best key lime pie on the whole island! first time trying and even my dad liked it who isn’t a crazy fan of key lime pie. we are still craving it!

Title says it all. Key lime pie was just above grocery store key lime pie. Also got grilled cheese which was great and good coconut shrimp.