KEY lime pie recipes vary from super sweet to super tart. I think their pie falls in the middle. Nice people at the counters with plenty of patience for undecided tourist.
1 - 10 of 897 reviews
So we did the slow roll down the Keys from West Palm beach. We had a slice of Key Lime pie everyday. Sometimes twice a day. This was our favorite. Kind of a frozen almost ice cream texture. Creamy. Nice light but distinct lime flavor....More
The Key Lime pie was just the right combination of sweet with tart.... and the crust was just right, not too thick.... the carmels had just been made and they were exceptional..... what a treat!
Living in KW I've tried all the other "the best!" key lime pie places in town.... They're not. This is. Do the "tart" style and enjoy!
We've walked by so many times and never bought one until recently. We had the pleasure of tasting many times because of them offering free samples on the corner. Their Key Lime Pie is "crazy" good! You won't want one from anywhere else once you've...More
Excellent pie. Not the kind of Key Lime pie I usually go for as it has a top of whipped cream rather than the meringue I favor, and is frozen but nonetheless absolutely delicious.
I will make a trip from Miami to Key West just for the most exotic, delicious, and greatest treat I have ever eaten. Imagine a piece of Key Lime Pie frozen on a stick like ice cream and then dipped in thick dark chocolate and...More
The key lime pie, we chose the extra tart, was as good as expected. The person who took our order when we were there was disinterested in serving us, a vending machine would have been preferred. Small place, glass wall to kitchen made it easy...More
The Key West Key Lime Pie Co was comfortable air conditioned. Staff were friendly and helpful and service was quick. This was not the best key lime pie we tried in our two weeks in FL; it lacked a strong flavor.