My friend has been coming to Key West for 8 years and each year returns to Paradise Pizza. Honestly, I don't know what the big deal is. The pizza is pre cooked, then the slices are heated up in a mini oven. My review of...More
1 - 10 of 256 reviews
We found this place one night drinking in key west. The pizza is incredible and we have been back to Paradise every year since. This is not fancy, but the food is great!
To start with, we order pizza for delivery and the phone person required we pre-pay over the phone for the pizza which makes sense to me on a Friday night at 11pm. Order for one plain pie was given and delivered as expected. The pizza...More
We've been on vacation in Key West for awhile now and can say that Paradise Pizza has been our go to for excellent NY style pizza! Hot, fresh with a crisp crust, we love the Grandma and my daughter loves the Hawaiian, the slices are...More
We visited another restaurant and left before dinner due to the noise. We walked across the street to the Paradise and ordered a pizza. It was very good. The service was prompt and the chicken wings were also good. If you want pizza near Devall...More
Yes, I said macaroni and cheese pizza. You cannot go wrong with any choice here at Paradise Pizza. Depending on staff, the pizza can vary in goodness. Usually if its busy, the pizza will be hot and fresh. Most everything I have had has been...More