We tried it our first night on the island at the recommendation of a coworker. There wasn't anything wrong with the service and the food was - okay. It just wasn't anything to write home about. It was rather dark inside (they do have outdoor...More
1 - 10 of 197 reviews
Took the family for a nice meal. Steaks were very good and cooked as we liked. Shrimp were large and nicely prepared. Service was good and the restaurant was quiet and nicely lite. Prices were a bit higher than expected but not than home.
Baxter's has the awards that boast of the best steakhouse and restaurant but on this day it was a miss. The restaurant is quite dated and you can tell by its decor. The have a decent selection of entrees but we came to taste their...More
The service okay. Server not knowledgeable about wine. When asked vintage of wine she did not know and did not offer to find out - tasted like old vintage. Menu rather unimaginative. Shrimp special was BBQ Shrimp with potato salad and beans (tasted like Campbell's...More
After reading some of the reviews on Trip Advisor, we almost decided to pass on Baxter's... so glad we didn't! "Hungry" for Burgers... we decided to give Baxter's a try. My husband and I both had burgers, served up any way you want them. Delish......More
This place was designated the best steakhouse on Amelia Island for 10 years in a row. That said, we were in the mood for seafood. We had the blackened shrimp and the seafood platter. No skimping on the portions here and very tasty, Oh... the...More
So we decided to try Baxter's again... The 1st time we sat at the very crowded bar near the kitchen area and could smell the grease and smoke. Service at the bar was slow as the bartender catered to the older ladies... Thinking this must...More
The food was very good, the bread delicious and the wine choices were excellent. But the server was rude, time and time again. Ruined the experience for us.
My friends live near here and come here often. They have a nice selection which is not too overpriced for fernandina. Nice casual atmosphere.
This resturant did not show up on trip advisor so we were surprised to pass it on coastal hwy and it be so packed w cars. Steak was good. Husband ordered the grouper which we did not recognize as it was not the fleshy, thick...More