Had a wonderful, hot pizza to go and the "family friendly" atmosphere was welcoming on a stormy night!

The service and staff are first rate and make you feel at home as soon as you walk in the door. The food variety is a bit limited, but the quality of what is on the menu is reliably good.

Great place. Nicest staff. Always greeted with Hi honey!!! from the lovely owner. Grinder bread is the best in town. I generally order the Italian Combo. The pizza is authentic Greek. As well as the salads. Recommended when in Old Lyme to get a great...More

friendly and attentive nice people who care about customer service and provide a good product for the price. Will return there no question about it.

Don't let the name keep you away from here. They have the best food of anywhere in this area. Prices are very reasonable and they have a nice little place to sit down and eat. I'm not a fan of thin crust pizza...BUT, this crust...More

The owner and staff here are really great folks. Easy to talk to. The meat lovers pie was chock full of goods. The Greek style crust was spot-on. The place has a neat ambiance and is very clean. They have a lot of to go...More

We have had several meals at Teddy's. Teddy and his wife run the place and are very attentive and kind. It has a diner type of ambience and has a lot of soccer memorabilia decorating the place. The pizza has a nice crust and they...More

Teddy's is decked out with Football (Soccer) Banners from around the world. His menu captures the favorites of Italian & Greek restaurants with pizza, stuffed shells, lasagna, gyros, greek salads and many more. Enjoy a meal and the friendly staff will make sure you will...More

Love the pizza, grinders and salad! Teddy and Maria are super nice and accomadating. Our grandkids love the pizza and watching soccer there!

8 of us Canadians stopped here for lunch during a conference. Great fresh ingredients. Would recommend.