We made it 1/2 Hawaiian 5-O and 1/2 modified Godfather pizza and it was so worth the eyebrow lift by the cashier. When traveling to Eureka this is worthy of a stop. You can also buy the pizza here by the slice if you want.
1 - 10 of 88 reviews
It is what you want! New York style pizza that tastes so good and is fresh! Excellent group of people make this pizza place really special and it's success speaks for itself.
Great pizza with large slices of a variety of types including vegetarian. But they could keep the place cleaner. Espically the tables.
Went in for pizza around 7:30 pm there were very few pizza selections left - and they informed us they were not making any more. So we had to settle for some pizza that wouldn't have been our first choice. Pizza was fine but not...More
I don't understand why we were treated so poorly. 8 people arrived at 8:15 on a Tuesday night to an empty restaurant. First, we were given menus with all of prices blacked out - you find out the price after you order! Second, we were...More
Paul needs to visit his restaurant more often because this evening was a mess. First no menu to look at? Have no idea what they have besides the pizza behind the glass. How much it is, how much a salad is once we found out...More
Very disappointing. If that's N.Y. Pizza I was born in the wrong place. Very mediocre. Paul should go back to New York and see how it's done. If this restaurant was in SF it would be short lived. I root for restaurants in Eureka but...More