Really great food. Great atmosphere. Pricey but worth it. Sit outside on the patio if it's nice out.
211 - 220 of 865 reviews
Intimate restaurant in a strip shopping center. Well presented, tasty, and reasonable price. Would recommend.
Fourth visit to Carmella's and still excellent...wait staff always know so much about what's on the menu and make helpful suggestions. Dimmed lights and layout adds to the ambiance. Food is always delicious and fresh. Highly recommend!
I heard that they served great Italian food and I was not disappointed. Service was good, food came fast, and it tasted great. The only downside is that it is very busy. When we left there was a line outside to get in. Get there...More
Being from New York I am really critical of Italian restaurants located outside of NY. But this place is the bomb! Awesome Italian food and first class service. I felt like I was transported to Brooklyn! The food was wonderful and the others in my...More
I come to Appleton a lot for business and this place is always on the list to visit. The Papperdelle entree is awesome! It is a small place, so large parties may have trouble getting in quickly. Just recently sat out on the patio for...More
We go here as much as we can for our weekly dates. I would it was only 1x that we had a meal that was not wonderful. The wait staff are very accommodating and they do wonderful little touches like a surprise cupcake for our...More
My husband and I came on a busy Saturday night. We called ahead and got a table within 30 mins. We sat at the bar first and the bartenders were very accommodating and friendly. We were seated and promptly got a salad and appetizer. I...More
I ate at Carmella's with two other couples. The restaurant is authentic italian. The appetizers were great - fried mozzarella, the napoleon (caprese) with both basil and prosciutto, and the fresh roasted beets which I usually don't like, but not this time!!! Only the ravioli...More
When you read the menu it's very difficult to choose. All seems to be delicious and when you receive the plate you confirm it. Will return every time I can. Italian food very close to real Italy. If there's something negative I must say from...More