Pretty bad meal. The clam chowder was very bland and starchy. The potato was hard as a rock at an early dinner seating at 7:00 and they said all their potatoes were that way. Fish was ok, not great.
1 - 10 of 64 reviews
On the way to and from Sandy Hook. It is in a strip mall where the A & P used to be. A family place that even sells fresh seafood right there. The Quality of the food is very good and so is the service....More
Family-owned local restaurant in a nondescript strip mall. Unpretentious but classy decor. Best seafood, well-prepared at moderate prices. Even the desserts are good.Known to locals, this business also sells excellent seafood by the pound at the front counter.BYOB.
It is an art to be able to cook fish to perfection. I come here at least once a week and I am never dissapointed.
We dine out at least three time per week. Our go to restaurant for awesome, fresh seafood is Naversink Fishery. Best clams and arugula salad. Rare to find our favorite trout always on the menu. Stuffed flounder is great. If you don't have room for...More
After being disappointed the last two times we were there (about a year or so ago) we decided to give the Navesink Fishery another go. We arrived with another couple at 6:25pm and told there would be a brief wait for a table for four....More
this restaurant is behind a seafood store,but NO fishy smells!! The dinners are delicious and always fresh and served with a smile. Haven't had a bad fish dish yet.also BYOB
Most consistently delicious seafood in the area! The Fishery never fails to please, best crab cakes (ALL crab), incredible seared tuna, delicious chowder, oyster on the half shell always incredibly fresh with great sauce, stuffed flounder amazing and the seafood pasta is not only heaven,...More