I went here twice during my short trip in Iceland! They only have a few selections, and I wish I was able to try them all!
1 - 10 of 64 reviews
I lived in Italy for 3 years and there are numerous places that say, "tastes like Italy" or "fresh from Italy" , whatnot, but this place lives up to the hype. The place is smaller, typical Italian style, quick and friendly service. Wide selection of...More
There are not many places that serve true Italian style pizza in Reykjavik, and Flatey is one of the hidden gems! Thin, delicious dough, fresh ingredients, and a perfect mix of classical pizza and "hip" combinations, like the hot and sweet Padrino, or the Nutella...More
The Pizzas are by far the best Pizzas in Iceland. You will have to be there before 18:00 otherwise you could expect to wait a hour for table. I really recommend the Pizzas, real Italian taste. The only downside is maybe lack of number of...More
Flatey was on my list when I came to Iceland and I wasn't disappointed. The pizzeria is busy almost every time but waiting 20minutes for pizza is worth it. The slices are very tasty, full of flavour and seasonings. You can choose from variety of...More
Found this place by accident and it was absolutely amazing. The pizza is some of the best I’ve ever had. Definitely not what I expected to be eating in Iceland! The restaurant was filled with locals and had a constant stream of people coming in....More
Great ambiance; pleasant staff. The pizza was tasty and hot. Mothers leave their babies in the strollers outside in front of the window (common in Iceland). Highly recommend when you’re in town and yearning for pizza.
This place is apparently known for its dough and how quickly the pizzas cook. We ordered two pizzas to split between four people. One was a prosciutto and arugula and the other was a mozzarella meatball and parmesan. They were both yummy! The crust is...More
We had Parma and Umberto to share between 3 of us. Both where good especially Umberto. The doe was soft and reminded me of a wery good pizza I had in Naples some years ago. We are coming back.