We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Key Lime Pie...served on styrofoam. - Picture of Key West Key Lime Pie Co

Photo: Key Lime Pie...served on styrofoam.

From Review : Just OK, considering their name of Key West Key Lime Pie Co

Key West Key Lime Pie Co

1286 reviews
#86 of 339 restaurants in Key West
  • Key Lime Pie...served on styrofoam.
  • it was ok ....
  • I don't understand the hype...
Key Lime Pie...served on styrofoam.
it was ok ....
I don't understand the hype...
Corner Greene & Ann streets
Not Average, Not Very Good, But Good!
it was ok ....

Other Recent Reviews

birthday
January 2023
Absolutely delicious
January 2023
Read all 1,286 reviews
La-Chica-Negra wrote a review Feb 2016
Marshfield, Wisconsin345 contributions59 helpful votes
Just OK, considering their name
I guess I expected more from a company that calls themselves the Key Lime Pie Co. and is located in the Heart of the Keys. First of all, I'm a Key Lime Pie NUT...absolutely fanatical about my Key Lime Pie! Slicing me a piece is as good as feeding me the whole pie because I'm…
Read more
Date of visit: January 2016
Been to Key West Key Lime Pie Co? Share your experience!