We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
My girlfriend and I spent a couple nights on the Vineyard visiting friends and stayed at the Edgartown Inn. The inn is quintessential New England island accommodations. Big front porch with comfy chairs for morning coffee and people watching. Very close walk to town for...More
My husband and I recently visited Martha's Vineyard for the first time, and our stay at the Edgartown Inn turned out to be the perfect lodging decision. This historical home is beautiful and clean and is clearly a labor of love for its manager, Sandi....More
Response from Sandi H, Manager at The Edgartown InnResponded 23 November 2016
Dear Michiganneese....thank you for taking the time to write your very kind review. I am thrilled that your time with us was so special and that we exceeded your expectations. Thank you so much for appreciating who we are. I look forward to having you...More
From the moment you walk through the front door of this beautiful Inn, you can tell that you're in for a wonderful experience. The place is filled with beauty and charm. The staff are warm and friendly. It's apparent that they love what they do...More
Maybe not even average.
Problems: heat hard to manage.
Electrical outlets : not enough in the rooms.
Decor: overflowing with kitsch. less would be a lot more. in need of a make-over. peeling wallpaper.
Breakfast? "Continental Breakfast"? : Bad coffee. a small piece of coffee...More
Response from Sandi H, Manager at The Edgartown InnResponded 3 weeks ago
Thank you for staying with us and for taking the time to share your feelings. It makes us sad to hear we didn't meet your expectations. I admit, there can be issues with a 225 year old house that don't meet modern needs such as...More
From my initial phone call until we handed the keys back to Sandy, The Edgartown Inn has become my favorite bed and breakfast by far. The house is immaculate and well spaced out so you kind of feel like your the only ones there ....More
Thank Patricia W
Response from Sandi H, Manager at The Edgartown InnResponded 4 weeks ago
Dear Patricia... Thank you for taking the time to give us such a great review. We are always happy to know we accomplish what our main goal is... and that is making every guest feel special, comfortable and leave with happy memories. It was our...More