We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviewsturn down servicehonor barturndown serviceisland restaurantfagers islandcontinental breakfaststarbucks coffeelit candlesglass of sangriafresh baked cookiesgas fireplacemarble bathroomrocking chairsromantic retreatblue heronsoft music was playingnightly turndown
I can't say enough accolades about this hotel. It is first class in a small package. The rooms are furnished beautifully. The bathroom has a whirlpool tub and a rain shower head. Each room has a deck and ours looked out over the bay. We...More
I recently booked this hotel through HOTELS.COM for a one night stay and received confirmation directly from the property. I was later telephoned by the hotel and advised that they would NOT be honoring my reservation because they have a two night minimum over my...More
We booked with Mary, who was so friendly and helpful, and her pleasant attitude really set the tone for our whole stay. Upon arrival, we were greeted warmly and offered Sangria. As parents we are used to Disney and other family resorts and this was...More
We have stayed at Fagers Island a few times and it has always been a pleasant stay. You will see the best sunsets from this place without any doubt! There are 2 separate places to stay on this property, The Lighthouse and The Edge. The...More
We stayed in the lighthouse itself, not the condos. We showed up on a Sunday night for a late check-in, and candles were lit in the room and chocolates were on the pillow. When I made the reservation, I didn't tell them it was for...More