We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Bay Street Theatre

Bay Street and Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
+1 631-725-0818
Review Highlights
Great theater, wonderful staff.

Perfect spot for evening entertainment. Nice bar and very friendly staff. Great show. Must try the... read more

Reviewed 1 week ago
Chris O
via mobile
Great show, seating in a semi-circle, wonderful actors!

I'd won 4 tickets to a show & took another couple to see Lingerie Affair. It was delightful. Very... read more

Reviewed 1 week ago
Austin, Texas
Read all 66 reviews
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
  • Excellent69%
  • Very good24%
  • Average3%
  • Poor3%
  • Terrible1%
Travellers talk about
“my fair lady” (5 reviews)
“comedy club” (3 reviews)
“no bad seats” (3 reviews)
Suggested Duration: 1-2 hours
Bay Street and Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
+1 631-725-0818
Write a Review
Turn Your Opinions into Points!
Turn your opinions into JPMiles
Turn your opinions into PAYBACK Points
*You can enroll in only one programme at a time to earn rewards for reviews.
JPMiles / Payback Arrow
JPMiles / Payback Arrow
Reviews (66)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

1 - 10 of 66 reviews

Reviewed 1 week ago via mobile

Perfect spot for evening entertainment. Nice bar and very friendly staff. Great show. Must try the Surly Penguin cordials!

Thank Chris O
Reviewed 1 week ago

I'd won 4 tickets to a show & took another couple to see Lingerie Affair. It was delightful. Very entertaining, minimal props, wonderful actors-actresses. Close-up & personal venue. Very enjoyable!

Thank Kayaker318
Reviewed 1 week ago

The Bay street Theatre presentations are truly wonderful, its always a delight, great talents are out here and perform so many times its better that in NYC. Its good to check their calendar and book your lodging reservations when you see what you want at...More

Thank ElizabethMain
Reviewed 7 June 2017

Celebrated cartoonist/author Jules Feiffer and theater & composer/lyricist Andrew Lippa along with director Jeffrey Seller have turned Feiffer's children's book into an imaginative musical about a talented, lonely boy who just wants a friend and his father to love him. This is a great family...More

Thank Janet S
Reviewed 1 June 2017 via mobile

Most of the shows here are wonderful. So nice to have it local! The bar is nice and socializing before the show is fun.

Thank Sheryl34347
Reviewed 14 May 2017

We have been to a number of tribute bands in NY & CA. By far this was the best boasting a 12 piece band with 4 brass components. The bar was open and the dance floor was full. Best birthday present I ever had. Not...More

1  Thank S D
Reviewed 2 May 2017

The Bay Street Theatre offers a little bit of everything: dramatic plays, musicals, bands. It is laid out in a way that all seats - with the exception of the obstructed seating which they disclose - have good views, We have seen countless shows here,...More

Thank PAM_from_LINY
Reviewed 14 February 2017

Wide variety of shows. Music, comedy, readings, movies, documentaries with discussion. A true gem for the community. The 3 main stage productions during the summer months offer eclectic works, so well executed.

Thank 929pat
Reviewed 6 February 2017 via mobile

Loved this venue ! Small & great sound. Seats are comfy & cozy . We saw the complete performance of Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band re created for its 50 th anniversary . What a blast !

Thank yanks105
Reviewed 22 December 2016

Let's see, we've seen plays, we've seen comedians, we've seen one of my favorite Broadway singers and we've seen that nasty neighbor from Curb Your Enthusiasm. What we haven't seen are documentaries. I love them, my wife doesn't; who wins? And we haven't seen as...More

Thank michael f
Nearby Restaurants
The American Hotel
263 reviews
.18 km away
Page at 63 Main
207 reviews
.20 km away
Baron's Cove
113 reviews
.15 km away
Corner Bar
118 reviews
.05 km away
Nearby Attractions
Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum
46 reviews
.53 km away
Havens Beach
17 reviews
1.22 km away
Sag Harbor Marine Park
13 reviews
.57 km away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Bay Street Theatre staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines