We’re always looking for a balance between comfort, adventure, and affordability when we travel, and were delighted with our 4-night stay at Pirates Hideaway on Salt Cay. The owner, Candy Herwin, is one of the most interesting, generous hosts we’ve ever met, and went to great lengths to make sure that we enjoyed every moment of our vacation. She was helpful even as we planned the trip weeks in advance. She suggested we spend our first night at Sibonné on Providenciales, and we loved the place.
Candy joined us on the flight to Salt Cay, and once we landed, we were greeted by the owners of two of the three restaurants on the tiny island. Dinner reservations on Salt Cay are essential, given the logistics of importing fresh ingredients and planning meals. Pat’s Place offers delicious, traditional meals like conch fritters, plantains, and rice and beans (called “rice and pease” on all the islands). We enjoyed the Wednesday “Conch Fest” at Coral Reef Bar and Grill, and had excellent quesadillas and grilled red snapper there.
With only five days to explore the island, Candy’s suggestions and quick tours of some of the best spots helped us avoid any dithering and get right down to enjoying ourselves. She’s written a beautiful coffee table book on Salt Cay, and produced a documentary on the history of the island. We highly recommend watching it if you visit Salt Cay; with that level of detail filled in so vividly, we enjoyed our travels around the island all the more.
We stayed in the first floor suite in the main guesthouse, and even on hot afternoons, found that the overhead fans kept the room breezy and comfortable. We’d read about bugs bothering people in the Caribbean, but only encountered a few mosquitoes outside after dusk. Long sleeves and a little spray around the ankles were all we needed. There were no mosquitoes in the room at all. There’s a super beach for collecting shells and bits of coral just a few minutes’ walk from Pirates Hideaway, so bring some small ziplock bags to hold your treasures.
We poked our heads into a newly renovated Salt Raker house on the property, with colorful piratical and sea life themes painted on the walls of the bedrooms by a local artist. The two other tourists on the island (yes, there were only 4 of us that week) rented bikes, but we highly suggest a golf cart. It’s a bit bumpy on some of the beach tracks, but after a long winter of being cooped up indoors, we loved having the warm salt air against our faces on our daily journey past the salinas and historic Bermuda-style buildings. North Beach was our favorite spot to snorkel. We had the entire beach to ourselves, and the water was crystal clear, free of the sandy murk we’d encountered on Grand Turk and Provo beaches.
Other details of the trip: we flew to Salt Cay with Caicos Express -- an excellent airline. At the beginning and end of our trip, we rented a car from Grace Bay Car Rental on Providenciales. Their Nissan Tiida is a great little car.
Bottom line: we can’t wait to go back!
- Pirates Hideaway Hotel
