We stayed here for 4 nights between stays in Florence and Rome with the crowds, churches, artwork and history. It was a perfect respite, beautiful, professional and friendly staff in a little village of its own.

I have been several times to Borgo San Felice, it is a very old small village made up of various buildings and transformed into a charming relais. It is immaculately kept with attentive and discreet service and not overpriced for the quality you get.
It is ideally located to explore the Chianti area and Siena.
The restaurant is slightly dissappointing, not much variety, particularly of local traditional dishes and a bit overpriced.
Las t visit we stayed in a large suite with two cots in the living room for the kids.
I also had a great massage.
I definitely recommend it.

We spent two nights at Borgo San Felice as part of our time in Tuscany. The hotel is unique and ideally located for exploring all the countryside villages in Tuscany and also Siena. As a compliment to our honeymoon we had an upgrade on our room and a bottle of champagne. The complex was an old village and now everything is part of the hotel. They have their own vineyard and wine tasting sessions. The food was very tasteful and the afternoons by the swimming pool were great. The staff is very friendly and helpful. We would like to thank all of them for our wonderful time. We will return to San Felice for sure.

Hotel Grounds - 9/10
Staff - 5/10
Wine - 9/10
Resturant Food - 7/10
Resturant Service - 10/10
Room - 6/10 (because of bad mattress)

This was a great place save a few items, here are my comments.

1. If you are staying there very long plan on looking for other dining options because you are literally in the middle of nowhere. The choices at the resturant are limited and not for everyone.
2. Don't go over the weekend (esp sunday) as everything is closed.
3. Sienna is close, Montepulciano is a snooze
4. The wine shop person was overly snobby and not at all helpful. I know a decent amount about wine and he was just rude. It really impacted my overall impression of the hotel. Additionally after purchasing a $50 bottle we were told we couldnt sit outside and drink it in the patio area. When we asked why we were told "it's not possible"
5. You better have something planned for every day or you will be bored to tears as there is truly nothing going on here.
6. Massages are highly overpriced
7. They need new mattresses and pillows period