Overall Gettysburg is overpriced for just about everything. This hotel is no exception, however when I travel, unless I'm specifically looking for a bargain on a business trip, I am willing to pay more for an upscale hotel. Not the best I've stayed at but certainly worthy of 4 stars. The pay for parking is ridiculous, Gettysburg is in the middle of nowhere and there are parking lots for attractions that close early enough that hotel guests could be offered parking in them.

My son and I just stayed at the Best Western Plus Gettysburg Hotel. We had a WONDERFUL time. The hotel is historic and superbly located right on Lincoln Square. Our room was very clean and spacious, with a lovely view. The staff was professional and friendly, free coffee in the morning, delicious apples at the front desk, complimentary newspapers, easy parking. Would stay there again with pleasure!

While it might be nicely located, the room were were first assigned was disgustingly dirtly. The carpet was so filthy, I wouldn't take my shoes off. We asked for another room and were given on. This was better...certainly not great. This hotel is trying to go "green" with their lighting. As a result there is super dim lighting in the rooms. It is impossible to read by any of these lights and it gives the entire room a dim, depressed feeling. I would never stay here again. There are too many other hotels that provide clean, bright rooms.

Advantages:
Central locations
Inter-connecting doors

Disadvantages:
Tiny swimming pool on the roof (no gym)
Pay for car park
Chintzy
On a roundabout (bizarre)

Side note: Expensive to eat in central Gettysburg.