We had a nice time staying here, would return for another visit
Pros:
Nice, clean room
Comfortable beds
Free breakfast
Clean Bathrooms (separate from the sink)
Location in the center of town

Cons:
Rooms on second floor can only be accessed by outdoor stairs
Beds are small to fit two
Smaller room than expected

The rooms were old and smelled of mold, the ceiling looked as if it was ready to fall in, the stairs going to the second floor, was held up, barley, by a then 1 x 1 very scary

We had to leave early so missed the breakfast which looked like it would have been nice. It was set up in a building across the parking lot from the main part of the motel .
The bed was too soft and whatever passed for pillows did not help make a comfortable night.
It was okay for passing through and Sheridan was a nice town to self tour but I doubt we would stay at that particular Best Value Inn again.

We were very unimpressed with this hotel. It was quite dirty (not to get too graphic, but there was snot on one of the toilet paper holders and dirt in pretty much every corner). I am not a clean freak, but you really did not have to try hard to see it. The beds felt like the type that are topped in foam -- way to cushy, I did not get much sleep. The fridge and microwave were handy, and the breakfast looked decent, but by the next morning I couldn't wait to leave. Hoping to find a nice hotel that takes pets in Sheridan since we have to come here for soccer a couple of times a year. So far, no luck!