We were in a desperate need of a break from our hectic job/school combos in Houston, so we booked Guadalupe cabin for two nights, 30 and 31 Dec. Since one of the nights was the New Years Eve, the total bill came to $450. Though Cotton Gin Village is defintiely a nice place, I don't think it justifies $225/night.
Pros: The place is authentic enough to enjoy that old Texas ambiance, exotic to both of us, non-Texans. Fredericksburg's Main Street, pretty and all lit up with Christmas lights, provided plenty of opportunities to window shop and people watch. Proximity of the Enchanted Rock Park and several wineries gave us something fun to do. We tried the restaurant on premises and, as we are both meat lovers, left happy as our both filet mignons were nice and cooked to perfection. $115 was adequate for two really nice appetizers, the abovementioned filets, a dessert to share and two glasses of wine - not cheap but adequate.
Cons: it was COLD (for TX, at least, +5C), so we were looking forward to that roaring fire in the cabin's fireplace. Problem is, the wood available outside of the cabin was obviosuly damp after recent rains, and despite of my fiancee's best efforts (someone who is used to building fires as he grew up in the house kept warm by the wood burning oven!), the fire was small and died after an hour max... and then the cabin really strongly smelled of smoke. The smell didn't tick me much but it would have been nice to have a real fire... Also, in their review someone mentioned "luxury bedding and towels". Not for us. The bedding was rather old, and bath towels so worn out (was that a reason?) that they reached the stage of only semi-soaking water off one's body. This is not something I would expect when paying $225/night. Also, thanks God that we were after so much needed sleep as Highway 16 provided its fair share of road noise, even at night.
To sum it up, the place was nice but would we comeback? Not at that price tag.
If you own or manage Cotton Gin Village, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
- Manage your listing
