I chose this hotel as a treat for my partner because of its entry in Welsh Rarebits which has normally proved reliable. I failed to research the hotel beforehand, had I done so I would have noted both that there were more "average/poor/terrible" entries on TripAdvisor than "excellent" or "very good ones" as also the arrogant responses of management to criticism.
Much of the structure of the hotel we found unattractive. Our room was small and utilitarian rather than in anyway imaginative even though we had paid for an upgrade. What is indeed a pleasant pastoral view with the sea in the distance is not enhanced by an oversize polytunnel-like structure housing the swimming pool. The staff were enjoyable but again, in the context of the claims made for the hotel, seemed inexperienced however willing. I was served cheesecake rather than the tart I had ordered as sweet. The coffee grounds were above the filter in the cafetiere and with no staff apparent, a trip to the kitchen was necessary to make amends. None of this of course matters in the grander scale of things and certainly I was not going to inflict distress on us both by making the complaints that legitimately might have been lodged with the well intentioned staff but ones who did not seem to represent the experience or responsibilities of senior staff. We enjoyed our meal notwithstanding all of this
What does matter is the cost - £290 for a night for dinner, bed and breakfast two, before any additions. Such over-charging for questionable service and limited and unimaginative rooms brings no credit to the hotel or Welsh tourism. The management, rather being repeatedly defensive, might do well to listen. Don’t visit until they have done so. There has to be an equality between price and what is provided.
Room Tip: You need a sea facing bedroom for which you will pay a surcharge. You will then have a pleasant rat...
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
25 July 2011
You stayed here for one night on 15th May. It is rather a long time to make observations through a third and fourth party two months later. It is a shame that you did not talk to us at the time when, if there were genuine grievances, we may have given some compensation.
Although you booked online, you failed to notice on our website that we may prosecute if libellous statements are made about this hotel. In your case, we were a whisker away from handing the matter over.
Our management responses are accurate and effective. We have received reservations as a result of them when people have sought re-assurance. We refer you to an article in “The Times” of July 16 2011.
You found the structure unattractive. This is a subjective matter for any building, let alone one that is listed. Your opinion would certainly disappoint the Mayfair architect who designed the main section in 1870.
You chose a standard, sea-facing room, three grades down from those of the top quality. Most visitors here are very content with ‘band C’ rooms, such as yours. We accept that the corner of the pool cover, principally sheltered by the estate garden wall and wood to the fore, is visible from your room, the most easterly on the first floor. Incidentally, the pool cover is a permanent structure by one of Britain’s top manufacturers.
We are pleased that you enjoyed your meal and endured minor niggles with grace. The cafetieres are regularly replaced. The two main staff attending you in the dining room have twenty one years waiting experience between them with a top catering student from Paris in attendance.
You refer to our rooms being ‘limited and unimaginative’. How many rooms did you enter during your one-night stay? Most would not agree with this opinion. Our website and brochure accurately describe every grade of room available and we refer to an article in The Sunday Telegraph July 17 2011 – ref ‘Press’ on our website.
You mention the cost of your stay as being excessive. We do not agree with you but would not expect you to fully comprehend the tightest of margins currently being experienced by seasonal, country house hotels. As it happens, we altered our pricing structure shortly after you contracted with us.
We have been listening to and learning from guests’ feedback for many years and, without the goodwill that we have generated, the hotel would have disappeared a long time ago.
You will be re-assured to know that the founder and chief executive of Welsh Rarebits and his wife stayed in this hotel, above all others, to celebrate a special occasion last October. They wrote to me afterwards: “Many thanks for a super stay – when can we move in permanently to Room 17?” Now these two good people really do have very high standards, as eluded to in your opening salvo.
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC