At first glance this place had everything going for it. Good location, off the beaten track, pleasant hosts and a good base for touring the highlands. Then you see the pool table in the guest lounge. Later you realise the bed is like a concrete slab and that there is precious little pressure in the shower when you want it. It's about now that you remember that the room rate is somewhat higher that the average for the area, but somehow the facilities you have on offer don't seem to match the price. On returning from a long walk on the second day you realise that the bed hasn't been made (just straightened) the room hasn't been vaccumed, the tea/coffee supplies in room haven't been repenished and the wet towels from the inadequate shower have not been replaced. Less than satisfactory considering (once again) the room rate. Interestingly, for a Scottish Country House, there is no porridge or Arbroath Smokie option at breakfast and, although there is an evening meal option at Auchterawe, the proprietor seemed to ahve no embarressment at all in telling us that the mjority of the menu was frozen produce, even though the prices were on a par with local restaurants. All in all the Auchterawe could be so much more than it is and, as such, it becomes little more than a big dissapointment. Auchterawe, if you're going to charge top rate and market yourself as a Scottish Country House, then you need to step up to the mark.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC