If the rating was just compared to other Knoxville hotels the rating would be excellent (Sorry Tommy, you're not quite the Four Seasons yet!).
A little history is in order. Knoxville has a slug of mid-range hotels that were all built 30 years ago in preparation for the World's fair. They are more than adequate for the business traveler but really lack any charm, luxury or comfort that a higher end hotel provides especially for personal travel. We stayed at Cook lofts for a University of Tennessee football weekend. The location is central to downtown Knoxville (which is quite nice if you haven't been there ever or in the last 10-15 years) and to the University.
The loft is large--in my opinion best suited for two couples or families over a regular or extended stay. There is a large kitchen which is not really limiting at all. You can do or make anything in there. The loft has a large dining area and large seating area to host company, and in our case watch football. It is really the perfect setup for a football weekend as the space has multiple roomy couches and a large HD television. It's perfect for the crazed football culture trying to capture every moment of a college football Saturday--all in the shadows of Neyland Stadium. It's guaranteed you will be hard pressed to find anything of the sort in any other SEC town.
The location is as nice as the space itself. We did not need a car for the entire weekend which is such a convenience when you can just walk back-and-forth from Neyland stadium and all the gameday activities.
Finally, if you love college football and have never been to Neyland stadium you must put it on your list. The upgrades and renovations to the facility have made it a very nice venue. The number of national publications that have ranked UT as the #1 gameday experience are well known. Tennessee has a gameday experience that is rich in tradition and a pagentry that is unrivaled in college football. Top off your trip with a stay at the Cook Lofts. Enjoy!
