I have stayed at this resort 6 times over the last few years - the experience has always been so good that an annual weekend here had become part of life for my husband and I. However, two weeks ago we had a VERY disappointing weekend here with friend of ours. After raving about it for years we convinced 2 friends of ours to come up for a couples weekend away. The popularity of the resort meant that we had to book months and months in advance, so we booked in October last year for a February stay. I knew exactly what rooms I wanted (having stayed so many times before) so we played around with dates so that I could book a weekend where we could have two studio rooms next to each other, upstairs overlooking the pool.
However, when we arrived on Friday February 3rd I was given two keys for two hotel rooms. When I complained that this wasn't the rooms that I had booked I was told that the hotel was full and there was nothing they could do. I was given no apology or sympathy from either of the two staff working on the check-in desk and simply told that they'd check in the morning if there was any rooms vacant in the area I had requested. The rooms were fine, but they were not the rooms we had booked - much less privacy and a different outlook. The hotel rooms have no privacy as the balcony area is connected to the path, so people walk past your room all day on the way to the pool. Disappointingly, we were not contacted on the Saturday about whether any of the upstairs studio rooms were available.
The service at the hotel has dropped drastically since we were last there in 2010. The pool was dirty and not kept to the usual immaculate standard. We had to ask at the reception desk for soap for our room. The fantastic Italian restaurant has been replaced with a terrible little bar which was empty the entire time and at one point had live music that was very average. The hotel staff were unfriendly (with the exception of one waitress who was lovely & a pleasure to deal with on both evenings). One of the best things about staying here for us has been the excellent service, warm & welcoming environment, clean facilities & great food. Disappointingly I saw none of this on our recent trip.
To cap things off, we had noise complaints from the reception desk on both nights at 11pm. Both nights we were in one of the hotel rooms playing cards. There was only 4 of us and we had no music on. Given that both couples live in apartments, we are well accustomed to keeping the noise down to a suitable level. We were simply sitting around playing cards - we were not yelling or blaring music, dancing or bumping furniture around, but just having a conversation. The complaints put a dampener on both evenings, and the weekend in general. The irony is that if we had been given the rooms we booked, noise would not have been an issue as the rooms are more spread out.
Overall I cannot stress enough how disappointed I am with this resort and the lack of customer service. I will not be staying here again - which is a shame as were considering staying here for a family reunion with 30+ people. Some other hotel will now get this booking.
- Oaks Pacific Blue Port Stephens
