Our weekend at Highland Farm was amazing, full stop. Oh, all the standard B & B things were present and accounted for - amazing breakfasts, unbelievably soft sheets (actually, we've never felt smoother!), a terrific common room featuring books and movies aplenty, gorgeous grounds and views - but two things elevated it into "magic" territory.
Those would be Christine Cole (a phenomenal host and innkeeper, managing to achieve the perfect balance between being solicitous and being overly "in-your-face.") She seemed like our next-door neighbor - but her apparently effortless skill became evident when she rattled off dinner recommendations and immediately interpreted what was most important to us into ideal photo op suggestions.
The other thing, of course, is the history of the place. For Broadway buffs. this is an absolute must - to stay in the same house where Hammerstein wrote some of the most memorable and iconic shows in American theater! Every corner of the house holds a story - and the many books that can be found in the bedrooms and the common area just add to that knowledge.
In short, nothing feels "new" in this house - yet everything works perfectly (even the flat panel TV and the Keurig coffee maker!). The magic of what was created there still lingers. And thanks to the wonderful Christine, we can experience it.
We can't recommend it highly enough. Do yourself a favor and go to Highland Farm!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC