The property is gorgeous and welcoming, and the bed was fantastically comfortable, particularly the pillows. The towels were very nice. I didn't find it to be noisy at all. The Asian man who checked us out (didn't catch his name) was extraordinarily friendly and helpful. The residential neighborhood is affluent and attractive. I didn't think our room looked worn down, though it also didn't look like it had been updated recently.
Bad parts:
They use Open DNS to block access to content-sharing websites such as You-Tube, Twitter, and Flickr. The woman at the desk that evening was not aware that the hotel had made this rude and technically incompetent choice and was unable to help. Once we worked around the problem (I travel with a computer wizard) the internet worked perfectly well, but most visitors will not know how to do so.
Our third floor room was a bit dreary. It appears that rooms on the third floor all have only one small window. If I were to return, I would certainly try to get a room on the second floor. This is an old house and I suspect that the third floor was originally the location for the maids' quarters, so you can expect sometimes low ceilings and not a great deal of light.
There is a fitness room but it is very small (stairmaster and maybe a bike) and has no windows. It is on the third floor.
