We stayed in room #16 at the SeaWitch from February 25 - 27, 2011. Our room consisted of a full-sized bed, bedside table, a desk, and a cabinet with a fridge built into it and a microwave on top. There was a small recessed space next to the door that served as a closet. The bathroom had a small shower, sink and toilet. There was a full-sized mirror in the bathroom, but no counter space.
The room itself was small but very clean. You could see recent vacuum marks, and the room smelled nice, like some kind of cleaner. The fridge and microwave were both spotless, and looked brand new.
The pool looked very well-maintained, although it was too chilly for swimming. The location is great, especially if you are planning on hitting any of the local bars. Everything is within walking distance. The SeaWitch Cafe across the street has great food. The Dive and the Fat Pelican are both great bars to hang out for a few beers.
If you are planning on hitting the beach and not spending a lot of time at your hotel, then I would definitely recommend the SeaWitch. All we wanted was somewhere to put our stuff, shower and sleep that was clean. The SeaWitch delivered that at a great price.
The hotel only had a few guests when we were there, and I imagine that during the high season it probably gets loud in that area. It's not a dealbreaker; just something to be aware of. But even knowing that we will definitely be staying at the SeaWitch again.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC