I visited BHI with two friends for our annual girls' weekend. I have to say they both enjoyed the area more than I did, and would probably give it five stars. Me, I like a little more action and variety (maybe because I already live in the country while they're from a much bigger metro area). Our house, Just Coastin, was absolutely beautiful, and a bargain, we all thought.
I found very little information about BHI online, so I wanted to share my thoughts here for others who are visiting for the first time. It is a beautiful, peaceful island, and we had a great experience with both the ferry and the rental company. Our entrance and exit to the island was easy and smooth.
Since this was our weekend away, none of us was interested in cooking. We forced ourselves to make breakfast, but we ate out all other meals during our 3-night stay. We quickly ran out of options, and what limited options they were.
We bought a temporary membership to the Shoals Club, as it was the only club to provide beach access, chairs, and umbrellas to members. Unfortunately, our second day (during the spring value season, not Memorial Day), they ran out of chairs. All 25 chairs were being used. The attendant told us more chairs were being ordered, but I was shocked that they didn't have more chairs on hand for such a large beach club! We were finally able to snag the chairs from another group as they left. Another small complaint about the Shoals club, the Sandbar Grille (this is an outdoor poolside stop) was very slow. We stopped for a quick sandwich before heading out to the sand and our stop took well over an hour. For cold sandwiches, that's way too long.
One other warning -- our meal at the River Pilot Cafe was very underwhelming. In fact, four of our plates were left untouched as we couldn't bring ourselves to eat them. The she-crab soup tasted like canned crab, the gazpacho tasted like stewed tomatoes, and the calamari was paired with a very unsuitable peach chutney -- ugh! I can't comment on the entrees as we didn't try those. I will say though, that this restaurant had the best beer selection by far. Our recommendation -- stop here for drinks before eating next door at Eb and Flo's.
The only other sore spot was the nature trails. We're all big hikers and were anxious to try the extensive nature trails on the island. Our agent from the rental company warned us against them, however, as they were full of ticks and insects. We thought we would use some insect repellent and give it a try anyway, but we should have listened to her. We're used to fully forged trails maintained by the Park Service, where as these trails were almost hard to distinguish, and seemed to have been made by woodland critters rather than adult humans. Further, there were spider webs just everywhere as a result of the trail being virtually non-existent. After having ticks, locusts, spiders, and more fall on us, we finally gave up and walked on the island roads instead. Take the local advice, and stay on the roads. You can have a beautiful nature walk without ever going on the trails.
I wanted to type out our issues to warn others to beware of these things when they go here on vacation, not to discourage anyone from visiting. I want to emphasize that it truly is a wonderful place to visit and a beautiful island!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC