I have traveled a lot and I give top marks Villa Eva. The family who owns and runs the hotel is wonderful generous people! The hotel consists of several houses in various sizes scattered in an oasis of trees, shrubs and flowers. The rooms are different depending on which house you live in but in common is daily cleaning with towel change. Some rooms have views over the Bay of Naples while others overlook the garden.
Each morning a breakfast which should cover everyone's needs, yougurt, fresh fruit, bread, eggs, cold cuts and muesli are some of the content. After breakfast, you can spend the day at the pool where you can also eat a light lunch. If instead you want to swim in the ocean or walk in town, are both of these options 15 minutes away by bus. It is perfectly possible to walk too but you should be aware that the island has a height difference of a total of 586 meters, for an untrained, some roads seem tough.
I have stayed at Villa Eva on seven occasions, a total of three months together, so I know what I give my highest rating for!

When reading the reviews for Villa Eva, the pitfalls of using trip advisor are there for all to see. We booked first and then read the reviews, so on arrival did not know whether to expect a dump or paradise.
We were at the villa at the same time as the people who posted the review complaining a cat got into their room, and they spoke to the owner in a very rude and objectionable manner about something that was essentially their own fault - they left their room open, and a cat wandered in. Some people are difficult guests and will complain about anything.
Our triple room was clean and spacious, with a sitting out area overlooking the garden.
The breakfast was good and the pool kept in immaculate order.
The bar was open in the evening for drinks, this may be a new development.
The short walk into Anacapri is not difficult and you can also walk down to the blue grotto and free swimming area.
The owner will provide a socket adaptor free of charge and gives free lifts to the port.
The only thing I did not like was the 10 euro per night charge for air conditioning, which I thought was excessive.
The gardens are tropical and well kept - but you need to use insect repellent in the morning and evening.
For value 3 out of 5 may be unfair because everything on Capri is expensive.

It was a lovely surprise to find the hotel was in a gorgeous garden full of colourful flowers and fruit. I needed to relax in the middle of a four month trip so it was perfect away from the hustle and bustle of Capri. I also love to walk and explore and soon got to know the local bus drivers. I had a week here and felt very safe and welcome by the whole family running the hotel. If you prefer nature rather than clubs then this is the spot!

There are so many lists of rules plastered all over this place, it feels like an army recruit camp. Our room was dark, stuffy and dingy. There was only a window in the bathroom, so we had to leave the front door open at night, which let the mosquitos and cat wander in and out as they pleased. Someone close by had their tv blaring till the wee hours of the morning, making it difficult to sleep.