Room size is good, and it is clean and convenient, but slight dowgrade due to the lumpy, uncomfortable bed. And hopefully you won't have noisy neighbors, the walls (and floor/ceiling) are thin.

We had a very pleasant visit to Hartman's Briney Breezes this weekend for our first ever trip to Montauk (it certainly will not be our last). I was nervous about traffic since we were leaving the city at 5:30pm on a Friday evening, but Robert assured me that a late arrival would not be a problem. Surprisingly we made it in right at 8pm, and he was there waiting with the keys. Easiest check-in ever!

The room was large, comfortable and very clean. I slept well both nights. The room was a bit chilly at first, but the heater quickly warmed things up. The close proximity to the beach and downtown was a definite plus, but it still felt secluded which was ideal.

We're already looking forward to future stays at Hartman's!

Great place to stay. Rooms are spacious and extremely clean. Nice view and easy access to everything.

My wife and I go to Montauk in October to fish. The last 4 years we have stayed at Hartmans. My wife refuses to stay anywhere else because everything is so clean. I saw the maid actually clean the windows inside and out and then she proceeded to clean the screens. The grounds are landscaped nicely and the ocean is right across the street. There is no place along old Montauk hwy to park so guests have their own private beach.